On Aug 22, 2007, at 2:25 PM, Alex Karasulu wrote:
Hmmm good point: I cannot imagine why one project would want a
different compiler plugin version or a javadoc plugin version. My
problem is once you start where do you stop? All or nothing is
what I would prefer so there is no ambiguity.
If it was all or nothing what would you choose?
hard question :-) I guess I'd go with all the plugins and no
dependencies. However I think that including all the plugins that
are used in all subprojects (and, perhaps, we're sure will be used in
any new subprojects) would be a good rule.
BTW shouldn't we have stuff like team info in the project pom?
thanks
david jencks
Alex
On 8/22/07, David Jencks <[EMAIL PROTECTED] > wrote:
On Aug 22, 2007, at 2:08 PM, Alex Karasulu wrote:
Yeah I'm not too keen on this since different projects will be
stuck on different versions of plugins.
I know reuse is a good thing but keeping the main pom light is as
well. I don't want any project
specificity in this TLP level pom since it weighs down projects
that might not need those terms
in the pom. Did you look at this?
http://cwiki.apache.org/DIRxDEV/top-level-pom-management-policy.html
yes but it doesn't appear to relate to what I'm suggesting. Right
now there are 2 plugin versions specified in the project pom and
nothing whatever else of any use to a child project. I think
either all the basic release management functionality should have
its versions specified in the project pom or it should be
eliminated -- right now it's providing almost no value. Why would
we want different subprojects using different compiler or javadoc
plugin versions? I'm just thinking of taking the stuff that every
subproject has to use and putting it in project.
In any case this is a really minor issue and if you are happy with
things as they are I'll revert my changes to project:8-SNAPSHOT
thanks
david jencks
Alex
On 8/20/07, David Jencks < [EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
What would people think about moving most of the pluginManagement
into the project/pom.xml and releasing a version 8 for 1.5.1?
I think it would be even better to get more project info in there but
I'm not sure I'm prepared to do that this week. I would be able to
move a bunch of pluginManagement.
thanks
david jencks
