On 10/01/2019 08:59, chenwei qi wrote: > Hi Mark, > > Thanks for your kindly review. I will answer your questions orderly as > following: > >> Who is the "we" that will be checking? > The PPMC members will check the list and they will decide the checking > date. As the meetup will be held on Jan.19, I suggest the check works from > Jan.14 to Jan.16, last 3 days. > >> What will they be checking for? > As it is the 1st time Apache Dubbo™ Meetup will be held in Guangzhou, face > to face discussion among deep users there can be useful. But the meetup > registration can be up to 300-400, too many for discussion. Check from the > registration information is to select out the deep user. > >> Where is the on-list discussion that decided a) that checking was > required and b) what to check for? > The criteria of user selection is not suitable to be discussed publicly, I > think it is better to discuss with Dubbo PPMC privately.
You appear to have missed the key point. A whole bunch of decisions appear to have been made about a Dubbo event with ZERO discussion of those decisions on any Dubbo mailing list. Public or private. That is simply not how podlings are expected to operate. What is most worrying is that at no point did any PPMC member say during these off-list discussions "Hang on. We should be doing this on the mailing list." I also disagree that the criteria need to be discussed in private but that point is debatable. Mark
