Hi,

-1 (binding) due to binaries in source release and unknown license issues

It’s a good idea to put [VOTE]” is the subject title so people know it’s a vote 
and to give the artifacts a release candidate name. e.g. RC1, RC2 etc so it 
doesn’t become confusing release candidate which you are voting on.

I checked:
- signatures and hashes correct
- LICENSE and NOTICE exist
- I think 3rd party license information is missing from LICENSE
- A large number of source files are missing ASF headers e.g. [1][2]
- There are unexpected binaries in the source release [3][4][5][6]. ASF release 
sneed to consist of source code and contain no compiled code.

LICENSE seem to be missing included 3rd party licensed code. For instance there 
are a number of files with "Copyright 1999-2011 Alibaba Group.” e.g [7][8]. 
That second file seem to come from here [9] and is MIT licensed so this file 
also has the incorrect header. This is code form here [10] of unknown license. 
These files [11][12][13] seem to have a different author, how are they 
licensed? As do these two files [14][15] which seem to come from here [16] and 
I’m not sure of their license.

There’s a minor issue with LICENSE in that it should not include "Copyright (c) 
2016 ~ 2018 Alex Stocks."

Thanks,
Justin

1. dubbo-go-1.1.0/cluster/loadbalance/least_active_test.go
2. dubbo-go-1.1.0/examples/dubbo/go-client/assembly/common/build.sh
3. 
dubbo-go-1.1.0/config_center/zookeeper/zookeeper-4unitest/contrib/fatjar/zookeeper-3.4.9-fatjar.jar
4. 
dubbo-go-1.1.0/registry/zookeeper/zookeeper-4unitest/contrib/fatjar/zookeeper-3.4.9-fatjar.jar
5. 
dubbo-go-1.1.0/remoting/zookeeper/zookeeper-4unitest/contrib/fatjar/zookeeper-3.4.9-fatjar.jar
6. dubbo-go-1.1.0/examples/dubbo/go-server/app/app
7. ./examples/jsonrpc/java-client/src/main/resources/META-INF/spring/service.xml
8. 
./examples/jsonrpc/java-client/src/main/java/com/ikurento/user/UserProvider.java
9. https://github.com/JoeCao/dubbo_jsonrpc_example/
10. http://big-elephants.com/2016-12/fasthttp-client/
11../cluster/loadbalance/least_active.go
12 ./protocol/RpcStatus.go
13../filter/impl/active_filter.go
14. ./examples/jsonrpc/java-client/src/main/java/com/ikurento/user/Consumer.java
15../examples/dubbo/java-client/src/main/java/com/ikurento/user/Consumer.java
16. https://github.com/baozh?tab=repositories

Reply via email to