Peter,
Can you clarify - are you uncomfortable with the existing behaviour
where an attached artefact classifier is automatically added to the
Bundle-Version, or to the JIRA I raised to disable this behaviour?
Thanks,
Derek
Peter Kriens wrote:
This feels like a bad practice? I feel uncomfortable with the version
qualifier being (ab)used for identity. If two bundles are compiled for
different environments (I assume this is for generic info?) then they
should have different bundle symbolic names. If you use
Import-Package, the BSN is irrelevant for dependents.
Kind regards,
Peter Kriens
On 25 apr 2008, at 09:59, Derek Baum (JIRA) wrote:
add switch to prevent classifier being appended to Bundle-Version
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Key: FELIX-543
URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/FELIX-543
Project: Felix
Issue Type: New Feature
Components: Maven Bundle Plugin
Reporter: Derek Baum
Priority: Minor
I have a use-case for using classifier to create multiple bundles
with different symbolic names but the same Bundle-Version.
This is not currently possible, as the maven-bundle-plugin
automatically appends the classifier to the Bundle-Version.
Could some switch be added, to disable the appending of classifier to
Bundle-Version?
Thanks,
Derek
stuart.mcculloch wrote:
the use-case for adding this feature was for people who
wanted to produce JDK5 and JDK1.4 versions of the _same_ bundle, so
because the symbolic name would be the same, the classifier must then
be added to the version to distinguish them.
it is the intended behaviour for the above use-case, but we could add
a switch
to turn it off - it's difficult to detect whether the classifier
should be added to the
version automatically, because each bundling process is run in isolation
there's also no way to distinguish where the bundle version came from
in Maven
(ie. general config or specific to the classifier) once it reaches
the bundleplugin,
so a new switch is the only safe way to detect the different use-case...
--
This message is automatically generated by JIRA.
-
You can reply to this email to add a comment to the issue online.
________________________________________________________________________
This email has been scanned by both Message Labs and Paremus
internalsystems for viruses and inappropriate attachments.
__________________________________________________
This email has been virus scanned by Message Labs.
