Mandatory directive stoped working on OBR 1.6.4. It worked OBR 1.4.1
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Key: FELIX-2673
URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/FELIX-2673
Project: Felix
Issue Type: Bug
Components: Bundle Repository (OBR)
Affects Versions: bundlerepository-1.6.4
Reporter: Emily Jiang
I moved up to bundlerepository-1.6.4 from bundlerepository-1.4.1 and found the
mandatory directive stoped working. I have three bundles obr.bundle121,
obr.bundle122 and obr.bundle123. Their manifest.mf files are shown below:
bundle obr.bundle121:
Manifest-Version: 1.0
Bundle-ManifestVersion: 2
Bundle-Name: Bundle Plug-in
Bundle-SymbolicName: obr.bundle121
Bundle-Version: 3.0.0
Bundle-Vendor: IBM
Export-Package:obr.bundle121
Import-Package:org.componenttest.logging,
obr.bundle122;version="2.3";company=mood;local=yes
bundle obr.bundle122:
Manifest-Version: 1.0
Bundle-ManifestVersion: 2
Bundle-Name: Bundle Plug-in
Bundle-SymbolicName: obr.bundle122
Bundle-Version: 1.0.0
Bundle-Vendor: IBM
Import-Package: org.componenttest.logging
Export-Package:
obr.bundle122;version=3;company=mood;local=yes;security=yes;mandatory:="company,security"
bundle obr.bundle123:
Manifest-Version: 1.0
Bundle-ManifestVersion: 2
Bundle-Name: Bundle Plug-in
Bundle-SymbolicName: obr.bundle123
Bundle-Version: 3.0
Bundle-Vendor: IBM
Import-Package: org.componenttest.logging
Export-Package:
obr.bundle122;version=2.4;company=mood;local=yes;security=yes;mandatory:="company,local"
When I provision obr.bundle121, obr.bundle122 was identified as required
instead of obr.bundle123. As a conseqence, the obr.bundle121 cannot be started
after installation, as the obr.bundle122 has mandatory requirement of 'company'
and 'security', which obr.bundle121 does not provide. However, obr.bundle121
provides the mandatory attributes required by obr.bundle123, which also exports
the package at the version of which obr.bundle121 needs. The OBR provisioner
should wire the obr.bundle121 to the bundle obr.bundle123 instead of
obr.bundle122. It suggests the mandatory directive is not functioning in the
new OBR level.
Below is the repository.xml to represent the bundle manifest.
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<repository name="obr.eba12.eba_1.0.0">
<resource id="org.componenttest.logging/1.0.0" presentationname="Logging
Plug-in" symbolicname="org.componenttest.logging" uri="" version="1.0.0">
<capability name="bundle">
<p n="presentationname" v="Logging Plug-in"/>
<p n="version" t="version" v="1.0.0"/>
<p n="symbolicname" v="org.componenttest.logging"/>
<p n="Bundle-ManifestVersion" v="2"/>
<p n="mandatory" v=""/>
</capability>
<capability name="package">
<p n="package" v="org.componenttest.logging"/>
<p n="version" t="version" v="0.0.0"/>
<p n="bundle-symbolic-name" v="org.componenttest.logging"/>
<p n="bundle-version" t="version" v="1.0.0"/>
<p n="mandatory" v=""/>
</capability>
<capability name="service">
<p n="service" v="service"/>
<p n="osgi.service.blueprint.compname" v="ResultLoggerImpl"/>
<p n="objectClass" t="set" v="org.componenttest.logging.ResultLogger"/>
<p n="service.ranking" v="0"/>
<p n="mandatory" v=""/>
</capability>
<require extend="false"
filter="(&(package=org.osgi.framework)(version>=1.3.0)(version<=2.0.0)(!(version=2.0.0)))"
multiple="false" name="package" optional="false">Requires package with
attributes {package=org.osgi.framework, version=[1.3.0,2.0.0)}</require>
</resource>
<resource id="obr.bundle121/3.0.0" presentationname="Bundle Plug-in"
symbolicname="obr.bundle121" uri="" version="3.0.0">
<capability name="bundle">
<p n="presentationname" v="Bundle Plug-in"/>
<p n="version" t="version" v="3.0.0"/>
<p n="symbolicname" v="obr.bundle121"/>
<p n="Bundle-ManifestVersion" v="2"/>
<p n="mandatory" v=""/>
</capability>
<capability name="package">
<p n="package" v="obr.bundle121"/>
<p n="version" t="version" v="0.0.0"/>
<p n="bundle-symbolic-name" v="obr.bundle121"/>
<p n="bundle-version" t="version" v="3.0.0"/>
<p n="mandatory" v=""/>
</capability>
<require extend="false"
filter="(&(package=org.componenttest.logging)(version>=0.0.0))"
multiple="false" name="package" optional="false">Requires package with
attributes {package=org.componenttest.logging, version=0.0.0}</require>
<require extend="false"
filter="(&(package=obr.bundle122)(version>=2.3.0)(local=yes)(company=mood)(mandatory:<*local,
company))" multiple="false" name="package" optional="false">Requires package
with attributes {package=obr.bundle122, version=2.3.0, local=yes,
company=mood}</require>
</resource>
<resource id="obr.bundle122/1.0.0" presentationname="Bundle Plug-in"
symbolicname="obr.bundle122" uri="" version="1.0.0">
<capability name="bundle">
<p n="presentationname" v="Bundle Plug-in"/>
<p n="version" t="version" v="1.0.0"/>
<p n="symbolicname" v="obr.bundle122"/>
<p n="Bundle-ManifestVersion" v="2"/>
<p n="mandatory" v=""/>
</capability>
<capability name="package">
<p n="security" v="yes"/>
<p n="mandatory" v="company,security"/>
<p n="package" v="obr.bundle122"/>
<p n="version" t="version" v="3"/>
<p n="local" v="yes"/>
<p n="bundle-symbolic-name" v="obr.bundle122"/>
<p n="company" v="mood"/>
<p n="bundle-version" t="version" v="1.0.0"/>
</capability>
<require extend="false"
filter="(&(package=org.componenttest.logging)(version>=0.0.0))"
multiple="false" name="package" optional="false">Requires package with
attributes {package=org.componenttest.logging, version=0.0.0}</require>
</resource>
<resource id="obr.bundle123/3.0.0" presentationname="Bundle Plug-in"
symbolicname="obr.bundle123" uri="" version="3.0.0">
<capability name="bundle">
<p n="presentationname" v="Bundle Plug-in"/>
<p n="version" t="version" v="3.0"/>
<p n="symbolicname" v="obr.bundle123"/>
<p n="Bundle-ManifestVersion" v="2"/>
<p n="mandatory" v=""/>
</capability>
<capability name="package">
<p n="security" v="yes"/>
<p n="mandatory" v="company,local"/>
<p n="package" v="obr.bundle122"/>
<p n="version" t="version" v="2.4"/>
<p n="local" v="yes"/>
<p n="bundle-symbolic-name" v="obr.bundle123"/>
<p n="company" v="mood"/>
<p n="bundle-version" t="version" v="3.0.0"/>
</capability>
<require extend="false"
filter="(&(package=org.componenttest.logging)(version>=0.0.0))"
multiple="false" name="package" optional="false">Requires package with
attributes {package=org.componenttest.logging, version=0.0.0}</require>
</resource>
</repository>
Are there any xml changes in mandatory directive expression between version
1.4.1 and 1.6.4? If not, there is a regression, as it works on
bundlerepsoitory-1.4.1.
--
This message is automatically generated by JIRA.
-
You can reply to this email to add a comment to the issue online.
