Re: Including sources in bundles

[Ferry Huberts]

On 23/04/17 19:14, Ferry Huberts wrote:

I have this in my products (cnf/build.bnd), might be helpful.

# To include source and debug information in the Eclipse build but NOT

it's only about sources here, it's an incomplete copy/paste
if you also want this about debug then you can add

javac.debug:             ${if;${gestalt;batch};off;on}

I think you'll get the point :-)


F.

in the
# gradle build, uncomment the following lines:
-sources:                ${if;${gestalt;batch};false;true}

Ferry

On 23/04/17 17:36, David Jencks wrote:

I mean OSGI-OPT.

The source jars for released versions are at maven central, but I was debugging trunk, and the source jars aren’t built automatically (and, actually I thought of adding source to the bundle and didn’t think of building the source jar). Wrong list — but would dragging/dropping a source jar into the bndtools “local” repo add it to the existing bundle?

I still think that having one artifact rather than two is more convenient, even if bndtools finds a source jar next to any bundle you drag and drop into a repository.

thanks
david jencks

On Apr 23, 2017, at 7:21 AM, Thomas Watson <tjw...@gmail.com> wrote:

I think including source is fine.

Did you mean OSGI-OPT instead of OSGI-INF. The spec recommends OSGI-OPT be

used to include source.

I am concerned that bndtools makes it hard for one such as you to debug our

code.  If it is hard for you then it is impossible for the masses.  This
seems like a pretty big usability issue in bndtools.  Are not the source
jars published to maven central for the tools to find?

Tom.

On Sun, Apr 23, 2017 at 2:13 AM, David Jencks <david.a.jen...@gmail.com>
wrote:

Working on FELIX-5618 I couldn’t figure out a way to debug DS in bndtools without modifying the DS bundle to include sources. This is certainly the easiest way to get the sources visible in a bndtools environment. After

this experience I’d like to include the sources for DS in OSGI-INF as

recommended by Peter et al. I’d like to include the sources in the util jar as well, I think then the extender base classes will show up in the DS

bundle.

Any objections?

thanks
david jencks

--
Ferry Huberts