Hello Arnold, - I am trying to show where to put the JMeter in the project structure, not in a particular order. - The integration suite test cases are listed anywhere or it creates a test case report that can be viewed or exported for later review? - JMeter is not for adding an extra layer/step during the build process, but for being executed on demand. - About flakiness ... I don't get the point? Can it be explained a little bit more? - Proposal of another folder in the Fineract project is to add the Jmeter assets independently.
Regards El mar, 16 ene 2024 a las 1:08, Arnold Galovics (<arn...@apache.org>) escribió: > Hi guys, > > Despite the fact that I like extra test coverage, let's slow down a little > bit before rushing any integration. > > I'd have a couple of questions about these tests: > - Victor, you're saying these tests should come before fineract-provider, > so within the regular build process yet these are JMeter, performance > related test cases. So what are the assertions in these? I'm a little > confused about what these are. > - Did we do any cross-check with our integration suite if these test cases > are covered and we are not introducing duplication unnecessarily? > - The build times are already slower than ever, did we evaluate how much > increase these would mean? > - How about flakyness on these tests? > - I'm also interested in the general quality of the tests because > maintainability on most of the existing integration test suite is difficult. > > Again, I'm not against any new test case/suite introduction, but let's > clarify the benefits and the drawbacks. > > Thanks. > Best, > Arnold > > On Tue, Jan 16, 2024 at 6:44 AM VICTOR MANUEL ROMERO RODRIGUEZ < > victor.rom...@fintecheando.mx> wrote: > >> Hello Anjil, >> >> Version 1.9.0 is tagged at: >> >> https://github.com/apache/fineract/tree/1.9.0 >> >> Regards >> >> Victor >> >> El lun, 15 ene 2024 a las 23:42, ANJIL CHINNAPATHLOLLA (< >> anchi...@in.ibm.com>) escribió: >> >>> Thanks Victor / Mugabe, >>> >>> >>> >>> I will verify the test suite against 1.9.0, make necessary minor changes >>> wherever required and raise the PR. >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> Thanks & Regards, >>> >>> Anjil , >>> >>> Power Systems Performance >>> >>> >>> >>> *From: *Magezi Arthur <artmag...@gmail.com> >>> *Date: *Tuesday, 16 January 2024 at 3:35 AM >>> *To: *dev@fineract.apache.org <dev@fineract.apache.org> >>> *Subject: *[EXTERNAL] Re: API Test Case for Fineract >>> >>> Great proposal here. Anjil this would definitely be of great help. >>> MUGABE MAGEZI ARTHUR Software Developer and Process Management Consultant >>> emails: artmagezi@ gmail. com atmagezi@ yahoo. co. uk Mob: >>> +256704901261 facebook: Magezi ArthurSkype: marthur26The >>> >>> Great proposal here. Anjil this would definitely be of great help. >>> >>> *MUGABE MAGEZI ARTHUR* >>> >>> Software Developer and >>> >>> Process Management Consultant >>> >>> emails: >>> >>> *artmag...@gmail.com* <artmag...@gmail.com> >>> >>> *atmag...@yahoo.co.uk <atmag...@yahoo.co.uk>* >>> >>> Mob: +256704901261 >>> >>> facebook: Magezi Arthur >>> >>> Skype: marthur26 >>> >>> >>> >>> The Struggle the doesn't break you will make you, if you hold a little >>> longer under that fire you will certainly come out as Gold >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> On Mon, 15 Jan 2024 at 20:37, VICTOR MANUEL ROMERO RODRIGUEZ < >>> victor.rom...@fintecheando.mx> wrote: >>> >>> Hello Fineract Community, >>> >>> >>> >>> What do you think about integrating these tests on Apache Fineract. The >>> Apache JMeter Tests can be included in this way: >>> >>> >>> >>> Apache Fineract >>> >>> | >>> >>> ------Functional Test (Anjil contribution) >>> >>> | >>> >>> -----fineract-provider >>> >>> >>> >>> Do you have any comments about this proposal? >>> >>> >>> >>> Regards >>> >>> >>> >>> Victor Romero >>> >>> >>> >>> El vie, 12 ene 2024 a las 15:06, VICTOR MANUEL ROMERO RODRIGUEZ (< >>> victor.rom...@fintecheando.mx>) escribió: >>> >>> Hello Anjil, >>> >>> >>> >>> I think it suits perfectly. Because it will help us to evaluate, verify, >>> test the functionality between release. I.E. a possible 1.8.5 release and >>> the 1.9.0. >>> >>> >>> >>> And this is important because with the results the community can be >>> aware of the changes requiered on its applicatons. >>> >>> >>> >>> I hope to listen (read) other community members opinion. >>> >>> >>> >>> Regards >>> >>> >>> >>> Victor >>> >>> El vie., 12 de enero de 2024 2:12 p. m., ANJIL CHINNAPATHLOLLA < >>> anchi...@in.ibm.com> escribió: >>> >>> Hi Victor and community members, >>> >>> >>> >>> I have a JMeter based test suite of Fineract (1.8.4) REST APIs put >>> together for the performance evaluation of our Infrastructure. I have them >>> classified into two categories >>> >>> 1. Setup Test suite – This contains set of APIs to setup a banking >>> environment, define products etc. >>> 2. Transactions test suite – This contains various frequently run >>> account operations (Savings Deposits, withdrawals, balance enquiries, >>> loan >>> disbursal etc) >>> >>> >>> >>> Posting below a screenshot of the test suits which can accommodate more >>> test cases into respective groups as the need arises. The test suit serves >>> the purpose of evaluating both functional as well as performance aspects of >>> the use cases across the builds. If we think this helps with the purpose >>> you are looking for below, I can contribute the test suits into the >>> Fineract GitHub (With appropriate modifications to be consumable by the >>> community). >>> >>> >>> >>> *Error! Filename not specified.* >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> Thanks & Regards, >>> >>> Anjil , >>> >>> Power Systems Performance >>> >>> >>> >>> “Success is not the result of spontaneous combustion. You must set >>> yourself on fire.” >>> >>> >>> >>> *From: *VICTOR MANUEL ROMERO RODRIGUEZ <victor.rom...@fintecheando.mx> >>> *Date: *Saturday, 13 January 2024 at 12:18 AM >>> *To: *Dev <dev@fineract.apache.org> >>> *Subject: *[EXTERNAL] API Test Case for Fineract >>> >>> Hello Fineract Community, I want to know if there is any Bundle of Test >>> Cases for Apache Fineract API Rest that can be used to test the Apache >>> Fineract vanilla version. - Create data codes (genders) - Create offices - >>> Create delinquency bucket- >>> >>> Hello Fineract Community, >>> >>> >>> >>> I want to know if there is any Bundle of Test Cases for Apache Fineract >>> API Rest that can be used to test the Apache Fineract vanilla version. >>> >>> >>> >>> - Create data codes (genders) >>> >>> - Create offices >>> >>> - Create delinquency bucket >>> >>> - Create loan product >>> >>> - Create client >>> >>> - Create loan account (application, approval, disbursement) >>> >>> - Create repayments. >>> >>> - Etc >>> >>> >>> >>> I know that we have in the source code testing case (unit/integration >>> test cases) that are executed as part of the building process, but this >>> question is more related to a bundle/orchestration of complete functional >>> flows in order to make sure that the nightly build or the release has a >>> functional quality check of its REST APIs. >>> >>> >>> >>> Regards >>> >>> >>> >>> Victor >>> >>>
