Thanks for this analysis. I might be missing the full context. Are you proposing something or working on something? Or just saying “there are big gaps in testing “. How did you assess priority of tests? Why should those ones you highlighted be prioritized? (Also, embed the document in a jira ticket as we can NOT rely on ephemeral google doc access.).
See my comment in recent email post that we may soon deprecate or transition all legacy integration tests… to be discussed. Ie we may potentially remove ALL integration tests. https://lists.apache.org/thread/sy8t5jgh782f02rzrd5l73bs4sl61pjs On Fri, Jun 14, 2024 at 8:26 AM Dhruv Sonagara <dh...@fynarfin.io> wrote: > Hello everyone, > I hope this email finds you well. > > I am sharing my recent analysis of the API endpoints and integration tests > for Fineract. > > The entire process was performed in Excel due to the absence of a direct > method to identify the core APIs being tested in a Testcase. Identified > several APIs that are not currently the core focus of any existing test > cases. These endpoints might require additional testing to ensure > comprehensive coverage. > > I took the following steps :- > > > - *API Endpoints Enumeration*: > Reviewed the Swagger OpenAPI specification to compile a list of all > available API endpoints for Fineract. > > > - *Integration Tests Review* > *: *Listed all integration tests present in the repository, noting the > core APIs being tested in each scenario (outside what I considered in my > imagination to be setup and teardown). > > > - *Lists Comparison*: > Standardised the format of both lists to facilitate a direct > comparison, allowing for the identification of endpoints used in the > existing tests. > > > - *Identification of Untested APIs*: > Determines which APIs are not the core focus of any current test cases > by comparing the lists. > > > - *Relevancy-Based Selection*: > Based on functional relevance, I identified the main APIs for which > new test cases need to be written to ensure these endpoints are adequately > tested as primary targets. > > > > *Next Steps:* > Please find attached *Fineract TODO Test Cases* > <https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1VjKsXDAIPXeTqhnn89-R4Kj63zqN5xT-rWGI4AsFmKQ/edit?usp=sharing> > for :- > The API endpoints identified from the Swagger OpenAPI specification. > The integration tests currently in place, along with the main APIs they > cover. > Labels for APIs not adequately covered in tests. > > Please let me know if you would like to discuss this further or need any > specific details from my analysis. > > Thank you for your time and consideration. > > Best regards, > Dhruv Sonagara >
