Hello Fineract community,
We are looking at a collections/negotiation scenario where, after agreeing with the customer, part of the loan interest and part of the penalty or fee charges should no longer be payable. We would like to understand the community's recommendation for modeling this with the existing waive and adjustment mechanisms. As I understand the current behavior: 1. waiveinterest supports a partial amount through transactionAmount. 2. Loan charge waive does not support a partial amount. It waives either the full outstanding amount of the selected non-installment charge, or the full amount of the selected charge installment. This was previously raised in FINERACT-591. 3. Charge adjustment supports a partial amount and creates a CHARGE_ADJUSTMENT transaction. However, its behavior is closer to a loan transaction adjustment that follows the configured transaction allocation rules, rather than an operation that only reduces the selected charge component. This was also discussed in FINERACT-2151. 4. On the interest side, there does not appear to be a dedicated INTEREST_ADJUSTMENT transaction type comparable to CHARGE_ADJUSTMENT. The generic transaction adjustment modifies an existing transaction by reversing it and creating a replacement transaction, so it is not equivalent to a standalone current-date interest adjustment. So while interest can be partially waived and charges can be partially adjusted, the two mechanisms are asymmetric in terms of component coverage, balance impact, accounting treatment, and audit semantics. For a business case that requires partial reduction of both interest and penalty/fee charges, it is not clear that current standard Fineract provides a consistent end-to-end solution. My questions are: 1. For a scenario requiring partial interest reduction plus partial penalty/fee reduction, is the currently recommended approach to use waiveinterest and charge adjustment separately? 2. Is there any existing plan or design direction for an INTEREST_ADJUSTMENT transaction similar to CHARGE_ADJUSTMENT? 3. From an accounting, reversal, re-amortization, or reporting perspective, is there a reason why a current-date interest adjustment similar to charge adjustment should not be introduced? Thanks, inar
