Hi,

> I expected the next step is that you put up a release candidate and open a
> [DISCUSS] thread, but not a [VOTE] thread.

Fair enough. I have opens a discuss thread but had very little response. Given 
we had a discussion open for over a week and no major issues have been found 
what do you recommend?

>  If issues are found during the discussion phase, you can just drop a new 
> package over the old package.  

-1 to this as this will cause all sort of confusion to exactly what version an 
issue was in or what version people tested and this could more RCs rounds not 
less and a lot more work for the release manager.  There are also issues with 
caching so that people may think they are testing the latest version but are 
actually testing an older one. It's not a large amount of effort to number them 
as rc0, rc1 etc etc but not call a vote until the later rcs and there appears 
to be no outstanding issues.

> For TDF, because it is an “app”, if you want more feedback, it might be
> reasonable to post a deployed version of TDF somewhere like your personal
> folder

OK.

Thanks,
Justin

Reply via email to