Hi, Just gave it a go and took a quick look at the release artefacts.
I notice the installer is asking to accept the Apache Flex JS and SWF Object licenses, this isn’t required as they are permissive licensed software. For Falcon JS source release: - The product name is possibly incorrect in the NOTICE file? - The NOTICE year is incorrect. - Probably no need (and potentially confusing) to have multiple LICENSE and NOTICE files in the release - RELEASE_NOTES are not upto data For Falcon JS binary release: - As for the source release above - Are we happy with the provenance of the files under /externs? (I assume so but just asking to be thorough) For Flex JS source release: - NOTICE file contains wrong year - NOTICE file contains Google Closure Library. This is not required [1], but if they (correctly) had a NOTICE file it probably would be. In LICENSE we have: "Portions of frameworks/projects/HTML/src/defaults.css is based on designmodo’s (http://designmodo.com/flat-free/) Flat UI which is available under an MIT license.” However that file doesn’t exist. Several other defaults.css files exist but they have Apache headers not MIT ones. Is something missing from the source package? Do we know the providence of the files in: ./js/lib/google/closure-library/closure/goog/demos/emoji/ Or this file - seems to be a phone coverage map? ./images/support_map.png There’s a fx symbol in these images. Adobe owns that trademark I think??? ./flexjs/FlexJSStore/src/assets/logo_blue.png ./flexjs/FlexJSStore/src/assets/logo_orange.png There’s also a few "Copyright 2013 The Apache Software Foundation” in several build.xml files. For Flex JS binary release: - As for the source release above - There’s a large number of JS source files without Apache headers e.g. frameworks/projects/Binding/js/out/org/apache/flex/binding/ApplicationDataBinding.js LICENSE is missing: - MIT licensed js/lib/google/closure-library/third_party/closure/goog/mochikit/async/deferred.js and js/lib/google/closure-library/third_party/closure/goog/mochikit/async/deferredlist.js - BSD licensed js/lib/google/closure-library/third_party/closure/goog/svgpan/svgpan.js - BSD licensed js/lib/google/closure-library/third_party/closure/goog/dojo/dom/query.js - BSD licensed js/lib/google/closure-library/third_party/closure/goog/jpeg_encoder/jpeg_encoder_basic.js Thanks, Justin 1. http://www.apache.org/dev/licensing-howto.html#alv2-dep 2. https://github.com/google/closure-library/
