David Jencks wrote:

On Nov 29, 2005, at 7:52 PM, Jeff Genender wrote:

I think it should go in the j2ee-server plan. IMHO the security should be available for all web apps, whether its used or not. I think it will be a PITA if every web app requires that import.

I strenuously object to foisting security onto every configuration whether or not it is wanted. A more appropriate solution is to make the security builder into a real gbean and let it add to the parentId if it is called. Please don't push us back into the miasma of a single plan.


What ever the solution, forcing an import in each plan is a bit much. If you have a better solution, lets implement it (probably post 1.0?). But I am as much against forcing the import in the plans as it will open up a lot of potential issues/JIRAs down the road. The import will be very easy to forget in the plan as we are now encountering.

I also hope you will correct the configId before you commit.

thanks
david jencks

Reply via email to