I always thought this was a feature rather than a bug. I believe
that what determines if you get security is whether there is a role-
principal mapping in the geronimo plan, not the existence of the
geronimo plan. I believe the same applies to ejbs.
I'm a bit nervous about changing this stable behavior this close to a
release.
david jencks
On Dec 18, 2005, at 11:04 AM, Aaron Mulder wrote:
Another major problem:
If you deploy a WAR with security settings an no geronimo-web.xml, all
supposedly secure content is unprotected! Try deploying this with no
plan: http://cvs.apache.org/repository/geronimo/wars/geronimo-ldap-
demo-1.0-SNAPSHOT.war
and then visiting
http://localhost:8080/geronimo-ldap-demo-1.0-SNAPSHOT and clicking the
links to "secure" and "forbidden". Both links work, with no login
prompt. Instead, IMO, you should get a login prompt and (since no
realm was configured) all logins should fail.
-1 to releasing without the fix. :) I'm sorry, this is the stuff
that's supposed to be flushed out during the "release candidate"
phase. We never had one since we were trying to get 1.0 out the door
in 30 seconds or less, but now we're having one, and I think we ought
to use it. I'd rather release a solid 1.0 in a week instead of a
broken one now.
Aaron
On 12/18/05, Dain Sundstrom <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
-1 to all "fixes"
We're never going to get this release out at this rate. Let's list
these as known issues and plan for a 1.0.1 release in two weeks.
-dain
On Dec 18, 2005, at 10:51 AM, Jeff Genender wrote:
Cool...I have a clustering GBean fix...so since we need to rebuild I
would like to slide mine in too.
Aaron Mulder wrote:
I'd like to put one more fix in here -- sorry, but I just got
back to
my internet connection. Right now if you put a username or
password
of blank in the database pool portlet, the deployment fails.
This is
of course required for connections to the embedded Derby instance,
and
I have the fix ready.
Thanks,
Aaron
On 12/18/05, Dave Colasurdo <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
Can we also address part 2 (shutdown error) of GERONIMO-1371? It
fails
consistently when issuing a startup followed by a shutdown..
Anyone have any insight here? If we don't fix it, we should add
this to
the Release notes as a "known issue".
BTW, looking through the release notes... I assume "Specific
Issues,
Features and Improvements for Version 1.0" is a list of things
that
already have been fixed in 1.0. We may want to make this a bit
clearer.
"Specific Issues, Features and Improvements *fixed* for Version
1.0"
Hmm.. Should there be a section in the release notes for common
known
issues (JIRAs) or do you feel that a link to JIRA is sufficient?
The
"Significant Missing Features" section info is much broader and
not at a
JIRA granularity.
Thanks
-Dave-
Dave Colasurdo wrote:
Matt Hogstrom wrote:
Deferring to 1.1
GERONIMO-1371 - Geronimo startup/shutdown issues
Any chance of incorporating part 1 of JIRA 1371? It is simply
adding an
@echo off to startup.bat (and a "launching new window"
message).
While not a functional problem, it sure will make a big
difference as to a user's first impression of geronimo..
Have attached the patch to the JIRA..
Here is the output with the fix:
C:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-1.0\bin>startup
Using GERONIMO_BASE: c:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-1.0
Using GERONIMO_HOME: c:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-1.0
Using GERONIMO_TMPDIR: c:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-1.0\var\temp
Using JRE_HOME: c:\j2sdk1.4.2_08
Launching Geronimo in a new window
Here is the output Without the fix:
c:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-1.0\bin>startup
c:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-1.0\bin>if "Windows_NT" ==
"Windows_NT"
setlocal
c:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-1.0\bin>set
CURRENT_DIR=c:\matt_spin_121805\geronim
o-1.0\bin
c:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-1.0\bin>if not "" == "" goto gotHome
c:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-1.0\bin>set
GERONIMO_HOME=c:\matt_spin_121805\geron
imo-1.0\bin
c:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-1.0\bin>if exist
"c:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-1.0\
bin\bin\geronimo.bat" goto okHome
c:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-1.0\bin>cd ..
c:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-1.0>set
GERONIMO_HOME=c:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-
1.0
c:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-1.0>cd c:\matt_spin_121805
\geronimo-1.0\bin
C:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-1.0\bin>if exist
"c:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-1.0\
bin\geronimo.bat" goto okHome
C:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-1.0\bin>set
EXECUTABLE=c:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo
-1.0\bin\geronimo.bat
C:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-1.0\bin>if exist
"c:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-1.0\
bin\geronimo.bat" goto okExec
C:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-1.0\bin>set CMD_LINE_ARGS=
C:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-1.0\bin>if """" == """" goto
doneSetArgs
C:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-1.0\bin>call
"c:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-1.0\bin\
geronimo.bat" start
Using GERONIMO_BASE: c:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-1.0
Using GERONIMO_HOME: c:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-1.0
Using GERONIMO_TMPDIR: c:\matt_spin_121805\geronimo-1.0\var\temp
Using JRE_HOME: c:\j2sdk1.4.2_08
