No, I don't think you have an unreasonable request. I'm perfectly ok with sending this to the scm list. I chose the devlist because that is where the GBuild had been sending it for a very long time, almost a year, if not more.
I'm even perfectly ok with stopping this if that is what a majority of us want. So far I had heard only positive feedback. But if there are a lot more negative votes on this, then I'll shut it down. BTW, like I said elsewhere, this is only a stand-in for the real automated GBuild that Jason has. Cheers Prasad On 2/9/07, Jeff Genender <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
Prasad Kashyap wrote: > On 2/9/07, Jeff Genender <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >> Are these really necessary? Can we send these to SCM? They are getting >> really annoying... > > I don't know Jeff. This came about b'coz some folks expressed a need > to see constant build notifications. It helps to catch and notify > build breaks sooner. It helps to save developers' time on building a > failed driver. > > Later, folks want this and more features like binaries too. > http://www.nabble.com/forum/ViewPost.jtp?post=8870930&framed=y > > It's hard to do a balancing act. It would be easier for those who find > it annoying to filter it out than for everybody who want it to run one > of their own. Sorry...I do not agree here. IMHO, polluting a discussion list with build notifications is a great way to get people to begin ignoring this list. There is a reason we have a SCM list...and I believe it is more-or-less for this exact reason. You in fact placed a nabble link above, which I really think is a great support for my argument. Although I can filter out these messages in my own inbox, when it hits nabble and gmane, this becomes significantly more difficult. If I am looking for an old email, I certainly do not want to manually filter my eyes through heaps of notification emails on gmane or nabble. May I suggest that we send these sorts of messages to scm or maybe even create a new mailing list? I think its more reasonable to subscribe to this sort of thing rather than push it on people. I would really prefer that the dev discussion be used for discussion and not be inundated with build notifications. If you think that this is a completely unreasonable request, then lets open this up for further discussion and get some consensus on this please. Jeff > > Cheers > Prasad > >> >> Jeff >> >> [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: >> > See the full build log file at >> http://people.apache.org/~prasad/binaries/20070209/build.log >> > Download the binaries from >> http://people.apache.org/~prasad/binaries/20070209 >> > >> > [INFO] Reactor Summary: >> > [INFO] >> ------------------------------------------------------------------------ >> > [INFO] Geronimo .............................................. >> SUCCESS [22.837s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Test Support ................................. >> SUCCESS [0.021s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Test Support :: Common ....................... >> SUCCESS [16.907s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Test Support :: Selenium ..................... >> SUCCESS [7.764s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Test Support, Test Deployment J2EE 1.3 ....... >> SUCCESS [0.016s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Test Support, Test Deployment J2EE 1.3 :: EJB >> SUCCESS [4.342s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Test Support, Test Deployment J2EE 1.3 :: WAR >> SUCCESS [7.356s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Test Support, Test Deployment J2EE 1.3 :: RAR >> SUCCESS [4.734s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Test Support, Test Deployment J2EE 1.3 :: EAR >> SUCCESS [0.273s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Test Support, Test Deployment J2EE 1.4 ....... >> SUCCESS [0.016s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Test Support, Test Deployment J2EE 1.4 :: EJB >> SUCCESS [0.603s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Test Support, Test Deployment J2EE 1.4 :: WAR >> SUCCESS [0.164s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Test Support, Test Deployment J2EE 1.4 :: RAR >> SUCCESS [0.086s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Test Support, Test Deployment J2EE 1.4 :: EAR >> SUCCESS [0.056s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Test Support, Test Deployment JAVAEE 5 ....... >> SUCCESS [0.016s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Test Support, Test Deployment JAVAEE 5 :: EJB >> SUCCESS [0.588s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Test Support, Test Deployment JAVAEE 5 :: WAR >> SUCCESS [0.124s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Test Support, Test Deployment JAVAEE 5 :: RAR >> SUCCESS [0.085s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Test Support, Test Deployment JAVAEE 5 :: EAR >> SUCCESS [0.054s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Modules ................................... >> SUCCESS [0.022s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Activation ................................ >> SUCCESS [52.492s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: ActiveMQ Embedded RAR ..................... >> SUCCESS [52.579s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Kernel .................................... >> SUCCESS [13.383s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Common .................................... >> SUCCESS [1.896s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Util ...................................... >> SUCCESS [5.152s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: System .................................... >> SUCCESS [11.473s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Management API ............................ >> SUCCESS [2.652s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: ActiveMQ GBean Management Interfaces ...... >> SUCCESS [0.580s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: J2EE ...................................... >> SUCCESS [1.062s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Interceptor ............................... >> SUCCESS [0.483s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Core ...................................... >> SUCCESS [0.914s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Security .................................. >> SUCCESS [11.477s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Transaction ............................... >> SUCCESS [5.427s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Naming .................................... >> SUCCESS [6.414s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Deployment ................................ >> SUCCESS [3.231s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Connector ................................. >> SUCCESS [23.565s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: ActiveMQ GBeans ........................... >> SUCCESS [8.600s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Web Services .............................. >> SUCCESS [15.250s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Axis ...................................... >> SUCCESS [14.609s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Deploy :: Common Config ................... >> SUCCESS [2.209s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Service :: Builder ........................ >> SUCCESS [21.499s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: J2EE Schema ............................... >> SUCCESS [10.674s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: J2EE :: Builder ........................... >> SUCCESS [7.675s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Naming :: Builder ......................... >> SUCCESS [6.617s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Webservices :: Builder .................... >> SUCCESS [6.822s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Axis :: Builder ........................... >> SUCCESS [2.560s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Client .................................... >> SUCCESS [1.156s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Test :: DDBeans ........................... >> SUCCESS [1.022s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Connector :: Builder ...................... >> SUCCESS [9.010s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Security :: Builder ....................... >> SUCCESS [5.793s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Client Builder ............................ >> SUCCESS [4.528s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Clustering ................................ >> SUCCESS [0.788s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Clustering WADI ........................... >> SUCCESS [23.024s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Configuration Converter ................... >> SUCCESS [1.032s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Deploy :: JSR-88 .......................... >> SUCCESS [3.227s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Deploy :: CLI Tool ........................ >> SUCCESS [3.016s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Derby ..................................... >> SUCCESS [7.256s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Directory ................................. >> SUCCESS [45.637s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Deploy :: Hot Deployer .................... >> SUCCESS [0.914s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: JMX Remoting .............................. >> SUCCESS [0.673s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Mail ...................................... >> SUCCESS [1.568s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: OpenEJB ................................... >> SUCCESS [1:58.747s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: OpenEJB :: Builder ........................ >> SUCCESS [8.460s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Timer ..................................... >> SUCCESS [1.345s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Tomcat .................................... >> SUCCESS [12.886s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Web 2.5 :: Builder ........................ >> SUCCESS [14.562s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Tomcat :: Builder ......................... >> SUCCESS [10.009s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Upgrade ................................... >> SUCCESS [0.831s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Transformer ............................... >> SUCCESS [0.499s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Persistence 3.0 ........................... >> SUCCESS [1.144s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Persistence JPA1.0 :: Builder ............. >> SUCCESS [1.707s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: JAXWS ..................................... >> SUCCESS [15.175s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: CXF ....................................... >> SUCCESS [55.900s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: JAXWS :: Builder .......................... >> SUCCESS [1.618s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: CXF :: Builder ............................ >> SUCCESS [2.338s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: AXIS2 ..................................... >> SUCCESS [1:37.564s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Axis2 :: Builder .......................... >> SUCCESS [1.778s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Jetty 6 ................................... >> SUCCESS [12.673s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Jetty 6 :: Builder ........................ >> SUCCESS [5.576s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Jetty 6 Clustering over WADI .............. >> SUCCESS [1.615s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Jetty 6 :: Clustering Builder for WADI .... >> SUCCESS [4.556s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo :: Transaction JTA 11 ........................ >> SUCCESS [0.771s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Maven2 Plugins ............................... >> SUCCESS [0.021s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Maven2 Plugins :: CAR ........................ >> SUCCESS [11.792s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Maven2 Plugins :: Geronimo ................... >> SUCCESS [12.054s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Maven2 Plugins :: Selenium ................... >> SUCCESS [4.103s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Maven2 Plugins :: Testsuite Plugin ........... >> SUCCESS [40.209s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Maven2 Plugins :: Testsuite Archetype ........ >> SUCCESS [0.122s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Applications ................................. >> SUCCESS [0.021s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Applications :: Welcome ...................... >> SUCCESS [27.131s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Applications :: Dojo ......................... >> SUCCESS [5.037s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Applications, Examples ....................... >> SUCCESS [0.019s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Applications, Examples :: JSP (JSR 152) ...... >> SUCCESS [9.742s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Applications, Examples :: Servlet (JSR 154) .. >> SUCCESS [3.420s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Applications :: Console ...................... >> SUCCESS [0.022s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Applications, Console :: Core ................ >> SUCCESS [3.036s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Applications, Console :: Standard Portlets ... >> SUCCESS [53.906s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Applications, Console :: Portal Framework .... >> SUCCESS [6.671s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Applications, Console :: EAR ................. >> SUCCESS [0.353s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Applications :: Remote Deploy ................ >> SUCCESS [0.908s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Applications :: UDDI Server Database ......... >> SUCCESS [8.912s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Applications :: UDDI Server .................. >> SUCCESS [1.026s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Applications :: LDAP Demo .................... >> SUCCESS [0.119s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Applications :: The Magic G Ball ............. >> SUCCESS [0.023s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Applications, The Magic G Ball :: EJB ........ >> SUCCESS [0.613s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Applications, The Magic G Ball :: Client ..... >> SUCCESS [1.295s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Applications, The Magic G Ball :: WAR ........ >> SUCCESS [0.632s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Applications, The Magic G Ball :: EAR ........ >> SUCCESS [0.116s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Applications :: Demo ......................... >> SUCCESS [0.116s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Applications :: CA Helper Application ........ >> SUCCESS [1.390s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs ...................................... >> SUCCESS [0.108s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: GBean Deployer .................... >> SUCCESS [1.992s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: JavaEE Specs ...................... >> SUCCESS [4.704s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: J2EE System ....................... >> SUCCESS [2.881s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: RMI Naming ........................ >> SUCCESS [5.818s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: J2EE Server ....................... >> SUCCESS [3.564s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Transaction Manager JTA11 ......... >> SUCCESS [6.870s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: J2EE Security ..................... >> SUCCESS [2.724s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: J2EE Deployer ..................... >> SUCCESS [8.196s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Connector Deployer ................ >> SUCCESS [4.567s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: System Database ................... >> SUCCESS [14.612s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: ActiveMQ Broker ................... >> SUCCESS [4.102s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: ActiveMQ .......................... >> SUCCESS [5.297s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Axis .............................. >> SUCCESS [1.616s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Axis Deployer ..................... >> SUCCESS [3.847s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Client System ..................... >> SUCCESS [0.258s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: J2EE Client ....................... >> SUCCESS [4.093s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: J2EE Client transaction ........... >> SUCCESS [1.839s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Application Client Deployments .... >> SUCCESS [4.089s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: J2EE Client Security .............. >> SUCCESS [3.178s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Clustering ........................ >> SUCCESS [1.370s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Directory ......................... >> SUCCESS [1.427s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Hot Deployer ...................... >> SUCCESS [3.664s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: JavaMail .......................... >> SUCCESS [1.502s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: WebServices Common ................ >> SUCCESS [1.433s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Jasper ............................ >> SUCCESS [7.149s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Jetty 6 ........................... >> SUCCESS [6.245s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Jetty Deployer .................... >> SUCCESS [4.191s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: JSP Examples Jetty ................ >> SUCCESS [14.103s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Tomcat ............................ >> SUCCESS [3.434s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Tomcat Deployer ................... >> SUCCESS [2.988s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: JSP Examples Tomcat ............... >> SUCCESS [7.843s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: LDAP Demo for Jetty ............... >> SUCCESS [4.694s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: LDAP Demo for Tomcat .............. >> SUCCESS [4.380s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: LDAP Security Realm ............... >> SUCCESS [1.596s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Online Deployer ................... >> SUCCESS [0.152s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: OpenEJB ........................... >> SUCCESS [21.857s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: OpenEJB Deployer .................. >> SUCCESS [5.358s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Remote Deploy Jetty ............... >> SUCCESS [5.531s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Remote Deploy Tomcat .............. >> SUCCESS [3.854s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Servlet Examples for Jetty ........ >> SUCCESS [5.738s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Servlet Examples for Tomcat ....... >> SUCCESS [4.317s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Shared Library .................... >> SUCCESS [0.683s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Shutdown .......................... >> SUCCESS [0.164s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: UDDI Tomcat ....................... >> SUCCESS [8.455s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Unavailable Client Deployer ....... >> SUCCESS [1.721s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Unavailable EJB Deployer .......... >> SUCCESS [1.675s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Unavailable Web Services Deployer . >> SUCCESS [1.725s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Plan Upgrade ...................... >> SUCCESS [0.763s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: CLI Upgrade ....................... >> SUCCESS [0.189s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Clustering over WADI .............. >> SUCCESS [1.806s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Dojo app Tomcat ................... >> SUCCESS [6.665s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: WebConsole Tomcat ................. >> SUCCESS [14.285s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Welcome app Jetty ................. >> SUCCESS [4.654s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Welcome app Tomcat ................ >> SUCCESS [3.285s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: CA Helper app - Jetty ............. >> SUCCESS [4.899s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: CA Helper app - Tomcat ............ >> SUCCESS [3.379s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Transformer Agent ................. >> SUCCESS [0.134s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Persistence Deployer .............. >> SUCCESS [1.996s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: OpenJPA with dependencies ......... >> SUCCESS [2.568s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: CXF ............................... >> SUCCESS [7.926s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: JAXWS Deployer .................... >> SUCCESS [2.361s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: CXF Deployer ...................... >> SUCCESS [5.555s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Axis2 ............................. >> SUCCESS [14.116s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Axis2 Deployer .................... >> SUCCESS [3.303s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Dojo app jetty6 ................... >> SUCCESS [6.422s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Jetty 6 :: Clustering Builder for WADI >> SUCCESS [3.928s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: Jetty 6 Clustering over WADI ...... >> SUCCESS [2.294s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: UDDI Jetty6 ....................... >> SUCCESS [4.644s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Configs :: WebConsole Jetty6 ................. >> SUCCESS [7.948s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Assemblies ................................... >> SUCCESS [0.027s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Assemblies :: Boilerplate Minimal ............ >> SUCCESS [4.137s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Assemblies :: Boilerplate JEE5 ............... >> SUCCESS [11.083s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Assemblies :: JEE5 + Jetty6 .................. >> SUCCESS [2:18.444s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Assemblies :: JEE5 + Tomcat .................. >> SUCCESS [1:51.097s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Assemblies :: Minimal Framework .............. >> SUCCESS [1:20.487s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Assemblies :: Minimal + Jetty6 ............... >> SUCCESS [1:18.126s] >> > [INFO] Geronimo Assemblies :: Minimal + Tomcat ............... >> SUCCESS [1:21.633s] >> > [INFO] >> ------------------------------------------------------------------------ >> > [INFO] >> ------------------------------------------------------------------------ >> > [INFO] BUILD SUCCESSFUL >> > [INFO] >> ------------------------------------------------------------------------ >> > [INFO] Total time: 31 minutes >> > [INFO] Finished at: Fri Feb 09 11:32:52 EST 2007 >> > [INFO] Final Memory: 145M/420M >> > [INFO] >> ------------------------------------------------------------------------ >>
