Kevan Miller wrote:
On Nov 6, 2007, at 5:04 PM, Hernan Cunico wrote:
Hi All,
the Apache PRC has sent a communication to all PMC's about how we (I
mean Apache projects in general) "thank" sponsors for their
contributions to the projects on the project's website. This type of
acknowledgment is not considered official from Apache, in fact gets in
the way for promoting the official ASF Sponsorship and Thanks! programs.
Going to a more concrete example on our website, we have a "Powered
By" page. This page has a misleading title for a start; we have been
carrying this one along for a very long time and I doubt it is up to
date anyway. The "Powered By" page provides a list of companies
rendering services and support for Apache Geronimo. So, at a minimum,
we should change the page title to something more representative.
The other acknowledgment we have is with "Graphics by Epiq", these are
folks who got voted for their designs when we overhauled the website
and console. This one falls into the same category as the "Powered By"
page for which the PRC communication seems to be specifically targeted
to.
The Search box also shows "Powered by Google Search", however this
might be a different case as this is an indicative of the type of
search the user will actually run -> external Google search on the
Geronimo site.
I just added the official "ASF Sponsorship" and "ASF Thanks" links to
the Community menu box on the left as instructed in the PRC
communication. We still need to determine how to deal with "Powered
By" and "Graphics by Epiq". The former should be at least renamed if
not removed altogether, the latter should be removed I think.
Hernan,
I missed part of this note the first time. So, apologies...
Regarding the "Graphics by Epiq" thank-you link we had on our web pages:
the request from the ASF PRC was to "track and monitor" our "Thank You"
pages. The basic idea is, make sure that we are giving thanks for
something significant and don't give away advertising that is out of
proportion to the donation. The PRC's intent is to encourage ASF
Sponsorship, not to prevent a well-earned thank you. At least this is
how I interpret the PRC request...
I think the Geronimo "G" graphics merit the continued gratitude of the
Geronimo project. I'd like to see our little thank you restored. Would
you be ok with that? How do others feel?
--kevan
I agree. Epiq put a lot of time and effort into our graphics and went
out of their way to accommodate our requests with several iterations. I
think they deserve a reference and I think spirit of the is to thank
those who contribute.
Joe
