I'm thinking of porting the work to deal with retrying stuff that didnt work (GERONIMO-5152) in the tx manager component from trunk back to the 2.1 branch. However, this changes the interaction between the connection management and the tx manager quite a bit -- the tx manager can now request an XAResource from the connection management rather than just getting handed one when a pool starts up.

So, I'm wondering what appropriate versions would be. I think that continuing 2.1.x is inappropriate for this size change. I think this would be an osgi major version bump. So at least it should go to 2.2... and trunk to 3.0

Another possibility would be 2.1 >> 3.0 and trunk >> 4.0 which is more consistent with osgi versions.

thoughts?

thanks
david jencks

Reply via email to