On Fri, May 7, 2010 at 7:54 PM, David Jencks <[email protected]> wrote: > Well, we've already confused all the 2.2 users who got used to starting > geronimo using the gsh script.
I don't think many people used gshell or gshell commands to start geronimo. I think most of geronimo users use "geronimo" and "deploy" scripts. > I'd like to attract karaf users who are used to starting karaf with the karaf > script. One of my longer term goals is to make geronimo more and more into a > bunch of stuff running on karaf. So, I regard the various tomcat like > geronimo scripts as legacy and deprecated. Well, I think we should discuss this direction in the community first before doing anything about it. Also, I don't know why we would need to attract karaf users in the first place. I certainly don't want to start geronimo server by executing "karaf" script or seeing "welcome to karaf" type of messages after starting the server. Karaf was a good starting point for Geronimo for the conversion to OSGi but I don't think we have to completely rebase Geronimo on top of karaf. So far we have been taking bits and pieces of karaf and integrating it with Geronimo. I think that approach makes sense now. Jarek
