Thanks, Kevan ! 2010/5/10 Kevan Miller <[email protected]>
> > On May 8, 2010, at 8:37 AM, Ivan wrote: > > > OK, thanks for all of your support, we pass the vote for Tomcat 7.0.0.1. > I will promote it to central repository later. > > Three binding vote : > > Rick, Ivan, and Joe Bohn. > > Ivan, > IMO, calling this vote was premature. No strict guidelines were broken, so > the vote stands. However, this is not how I would like to see votes run in > the Geronimo community. Please don't repeat. And I'll note that I would > expect the Geronimo community do do a better job of monitoring... Things > that I'm noting: > > 1) A bare minimum of 3 PMC votes > 2) There were several comments/questions on this release. There were > answers/responses, but no attempt to see if the questions were resolved > satisfactorily. > 3) You identified a functional problem with the release, waited 12 hours > and called the vote. IMO, this did not provide much time for additional > review or comments. No one said "I agree". > 4) The vote ran for 4 days (minimum is 3). However, given the above > conditions, IMO the vote should have run for a longer time. > > --kevan -- Ivan
