a) the re-ordering of often unchanged public methods - previously the
public methods were grouped by similar functionality which seems logical
to me but now they are in alphabetical order.  This makes the patch much
bigger and harder to read.  If there is a good reason to re-order the
methods, do it in a separate patch.

If it makes ANY SENSE todo such things, then you are NOT using good enough tools. Have your IDE run the "Code outline" in alpha order if it pleases you. The file itself should obviously be in functional groups.

Ordering after functional groups is _the_ way, not _a_ way.

'javadoc' also understand this: when making the html, in the first block, listing the methods with the first sentence, it reorders the methods into alpha order, while the second block with the methods with the full javadoc is ordered as in the class. Perfect logic.

Alphabetical ordering of code - I'm getting aggressive thoughts by the mere idea. Such evilness must be fought.

Endre.

Reply via email to