On Tue, Apr 29, 2008 at 7:49 AM, Tim Ellison <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> Nathan Beyer wrote: > > > Yes, this seems like it's a larger problem. We need to follow suit with > > the > > other VM vendors and begin utilizing the Olson zoneinfo with regular > > updates > > and eventually and updater tool. > > > > Why not get the timezone info via ICU since it is a dependency anyway? > They in turn get it from CLDR/Olson and have the tools for updating to later > data, including a tool to apply changes that don't take effect until some > point in the future! That sounds good too me. Let someone else do the hard work. -Nathan > > > [1] http://www.icu-project.org/userguide/dateTimezone.html > > Regards, > Tim > > > On Fri, Apr 25, 2008 at 1:38 PM, Tim Ellison <[EMAIL > PROTECTED]<https://mail.google.com/mail?view=cm&tf=0&[EMAIL PROTECTED]>> > > wrote: > > > > Jim Yu wrote: > > > > > > I looked at this issue from the JIRA[1]. The testcase works fine on > > > > RI but > > > > fails on Harmony in the second assert statement. > > > > I found that the returned TimeZone instance from > > > > TimeZone.getTimeZone("America/Toronto") on Harmony was "GMT" other > > > > than > > > > "America/Toronto". That's why the second assert statement fails on > > > > Harmony. > > > > I attached a patch to the JIRA[1], which will solve > > > > this issue. Anybody to verify it? If no objection, I will ask a > > > > committer > > > > to > > > > apply it: ) > > > > > > > > I ran a simple comparison of Sun's 1.6b03 time zone IDs with > > > Harmony's, and > > > there are quite a few in the same category. > > > > > > A diff of the sorted output from TimeZone.getAvailableIDs() is given > > > below. > > > > > > Regards, > > > Tim > > > > > > -- > > > > > > *** hy.txt Fri Apr 25 17:08:28 2008 > > > --- ri.txt Fri Apr 25 19:34:34 2008 > > > *************** > > > *** 7,25 **** > > > --- 7,30 ---- > > > Africa/Accra > > > Africa/Addis_Ababa > > > Africa/Algiers > > > + Africa/Asmara > > > Africa/Asmera > > > + Africa/Bamako > > > Africa/Bangui > > > Africa/Banjul > > > Africa/Bissau > > > Africa/Blantyre > > > + Africa/Brazzaville > > > Africa/Bujumbura > > > Africa/Cairo > > > Africa/Casablanca > > > + Africa/Ceuta > > > Africa/Conakry > > > Africa/Dakar > > > Africa/Dar_es_Salaam > > > Africa/Djibouti > > > Africa/Douala > > > + Africa/El_Aaiun > > > Africa/Freetown > > > Africa/Gaborone > > > Africa/Harare > > > *************** > > > *** 55,133 **** > > > --- 60,221 ---- > > > America/Anchorage > > > America/Anguilla > > > America/Antigua > > > + America/Araguaina > > > + America/Argentina/Buenos_Aires > > > + America/Argentina/Catamarca > > > + America/Argentina/ComodRivadavia > > > + America/Argentina/Cordoba > > > + America/Argentina/Jujuy > > > + America/Argentina/La_Rioja > > > + America/Argentina/Mendoza > > > + America/Argentina/Rio_Gallegos > > > + America/Argentina/San_Juan > > > + America/Argentina/Tucuman > > > + America/Argentina/Ushuaia > > > America/Aruba > > > America/Asuncion > > > + America/Atikokan > > > + America/Atka > > > + America/Bahia > > > America/Barbados > > > + America/Belem > > > America/Belize > > > + America/Blanc-Sablon > > > + America/Boa_Vista > > > America/Bogota > > > + America/Boise > > > America/Buenos_Aires > > > + America/Cambridge_Bay > > > + America/Campo_Grande > > > + America/Cancun > > > America/Caracas > > > + America/Catamarca > > > America/Cayenne > > > America/Cayman > > > America/Chicago > > > + America/Chihuahua > > > + America/Coral_Harbour > > > + America/Cordoba > > > America/Costa_Rica > > > America/Cuiaba > > > America/Curacao > > > + America/Danmarkshavn > > > + America/Dawson > > > America/Dawson_Creek > > > America/Denver > > > + America/Detroit > > > America/Dominica > > > America/Edmonton > > > + America/Eirunepe > > > America/El_Salvador > > > + America/Ensenada > > > + America/Fort_Wayne > > > America/Fortaleza > > > + America/Glace_Bay > > > America/Godthab > > > + America/Goose_Bay > > > America/Grand_Turk > > > America/Grenada > > > America/Guadeloupe > > > + America/Guatemala > > > America/Guayaquil > > > America/Guyana > > > America/Halifax > > > America/Havana > > > + America/Hermosillo > > > + America/Indiana/Indianapolis > > > + America/Indiana/Knox > > > + America/Indiana/Marengo > > > + America/Indiana/Petersburg > > > + America/Indiana/Tell_City > > > + America/Indiana/Vevay > > > + America/Indiana/Vincennes > > > + America/Indiana/Winamac > > > America/Indianapolis > > > + America/Inuvik > > > + America/Iqaluit > > > America/Jamaica > > > + America/Jujuy > > > + America/Juneau > > > + America/Kentucky/Louisville > > > + America/Kentucky/Monticello > > > + America/Knox_IN > > > America/La_Paz > > > America/Lima > > > America/Los_Angeles > > > + America/Louisville > > > + America/Maceio > > > America/Managua > > > America/Manaus > > > America/Martinique > > > America/Mazatlan > > > + America/Mendoza > > > + America/Menominee > > > + America/Merida > > > America/Mexico_City > > > America/Miquelon > > > + America/Moncton > > > + America/Monterrey > > > America/Montevideo > > > America/Montreal > > > America/Montserrat > > > America/Nassau > > > America/New_York > > > + America/Nipigon > > > + America/Nome > > > America/Noronha > > > + America/North_Dakota/Center > > > + America/North_Dakota/New_Salem > > > America/Panama > > > + America/Pangnirtung > > > America/Paramaribo > > > America/Phoenix > > > America/Port-au-Prince > > > America/Port_of_Spain > > > America/Porto_Acre > > > + America/Porto_Velho > > > America/Puerto_Rico > > > + America/Rainy_River > > > + America/Rankin_Inlet > > > + America/Recife > > > America/Regina > > > + America/Resolute > > > America/Rio_Branco > > > + America/Rosario > > > America/Santiago > > > America/Santo_Domingo > > > America/Sao_Paulo > > > America/Scoresbysund > > > + America/Shiprock > > > America/St_Johns > > > America/St_Kitts > > > America/St_Lucia > > > America/St_Thomas > > > America/St_Vincent > > > + America/Swift_Current > > > America/Tegucigalpa > > > America/Thule > > > + America/Thunder_Bay > > > America/Tijuana > > > + America/Toronto > > > America/Tortola > > > America/Vancouver > > > + America/Virgin > > > + America/Whitehorse > > > America/Winnipeg > > > + America/Yakutat > > > + America/Yellowknife > > > Antarctica/Casey > > > + Antarctica/Davis > > > Antarctica/DumontDUrville > > > Antarctica/Mawson > > > Antarctica/McMurdo > > > Antarctica/Palmer > > > + Antarctica/Rothera > > > + Antarctica/South_Pole > > > + Antarctica/Syowa > > > + Antarctica/Vostok > > > + Arctic/Longyearbyen > > > Asia/Aden > > > Asia/Almaty > > > Asia/Amman > > > *************** > > > *** 144,179 **** > > > --- 232,288 ---- > > > Asia/Bishkek > > > Asia/Brunei > > > Asia/Calcutta > > > + Asia/Choibalsan > > > + Asia/Chongqing > > > + Asia/Chungking > > > Asia/Colombo > > > Asia/Dacca > > > Asia/Damascus > > > Asia/Dhaka > > > + Asia/Dili > > > Asia/Dubai > > > Asia/Dushanbe > > > + Asia/Gaza > > > + Asia/Harbin > > > Asia/Hong_Kong > > > + Asia/Hovd > > > Asia/Irkutsk > > > + Asia/Istanbul > > > Asia/Jakarta > > > Asia/Jayapura > > > Asia/Jerusalem > > > Asia/Kabul > > > Asia/Kamchatka > > > Asia/Karachi > > > + Asia/Kashgar > > > Asia/Katmandu > > > Asia/Krasnoyarsk > > > Asia/Kuala_Lumpur > > > + Asia/Kuching > > > Asia/Kuwait > > > Asia/Macao > > > + Asia/Macau > > > Asia/Magadan > > > + Asia/Makassar > > > Asia/Manila > > > Asia/Muscat > > > Asia/Nicosia > > > Asia/Novosibirsk > > > + Asia/Omsk > > > + Asia/Oral > > > Asia/Phnom_Penh > > > + Asia/Pontianak > > > Asia/Pyongyang > > > Asia/Qatar > > > + Asia/Qyzylorda > > > Asia/Rangoon > > > Asia/Riyadh > > > + Asia/Riyadh87 > > > + Asia/Riyadh88 > > > + Asia/Riyadh89 > > > Asia/Saigon > > > + Asia/Sakhalin > > > + Asia/Samarkand > > > Asia/Seoul > > > Asia/Shanghai > > > Asia/Singapore > > > *************** > > > *** 181,192 **** > > > --- 290,303 ---- > > > Asia/Tashkent > > > Asia/Tbilisi > > > Asia/Tehran > > > + Asia/Tel_Aviv > > > Asia/Thimbu > > > Asia/Thimphu > > > Asia/Tokyo > > > Asia/Ujung_Pandang > > > Asia/Ulaanbaatar > > > Asia/Ulan_Bator > > > + Asia/Urumqi > > > Asia/Vientiane > > > Asia/Vladivostok > > > Asia/Yakutsk > > > *************** > > > *** 197,230 **** > > > --- 308,416 ---- > > > Atlantic/Canary > > > Atlantic/Cape_Verde > > > Atlantic/Faeroe > > > + Atlantic/Faroe > > > Atlantic/Jan_Mayen > > > + Atlantic/Madeira > > > Atlantic/Reykjavik > > > Atlantic/South_Georgia > > > Atlantic/St_Helena > > > Atlantic/Stanley > > > + Australia/ACT > > > Australia/Adelaide > > > Australia/Brisbane > > > Australia/Broken_Hill > > > + Australia/Canberra > > > + Australia/Currie > > > Australia/Darwin > > > + Australia/Eucla > > > Australia/Hobart > > > + Australia/LHI > > > + Australia/Lindeman > > > Australia/Lord_Howe > > > + Australia/Melbourne > > > + Australia/NSW > > > + Australia/North > > > Australia/Perth > > > + Australia/Queensland > > > + Australia/South > > > Australia/Sydney > > > + Australia/Tasmania > > > + Australia/Victoria > > > + Australia/West > > > + Australia/Yancowinna > > > BET > > > BST > > > + Brazil/Acre > > > + Brazil/DeNoronha > > > + Brazil/East > > > + Brazil/West > > > CAT > > > + CET > > > CNT > > > CST > > > + CST6CDT > > > CTT > > > + Canada/Atlantic > > > + Canada/Central > > > + Canada/East-Saskatchewan > > > + Canada/Eastern > > > + Canada/Mountain > > > + Canada/Newfoundland > > > + Canada/Pacific > > > + Canada/Saskatchewan > > > + Canada/Yukon > > > + Chile/Continental > > > + Chile/EasterIsland > > > + Cuba > > > EAT > > > ECT > > > EET > > > EST > > > + EST5EDT > > > + Egypt > > > + Eire > > > + Etc/GMT > > > + Etc/GMT+0 > > > + Etc/GMT+1 > > > + Etc/GMT+10 > > > + Etc/GMT+11 > > > + Etc/GMT+12 > > > + Etc/GMT+2 > > > + Etc/GMT+3 > > > + Etc/GMT+4 > > > + Etc/GMT+5 > > > + Etc/GMT+6 > > > + Etc/GMT+7 > > > + Etc/GMT+8 > > > + Etc/GMT+9 > > > + Etc/GMT-0 > > > + Etc/GMT-1 > > > + Etc/GMT-10 > > > + Etc/GMT-11 > > > + Etc/GMT-12 > > > + Etc/GMT-13 > > > + Etc/GMT-14 > > > + Etc/GMT-2 > > > + Etc/GMT-3 > > > + Etc/GMT-4 > > > + Etc/GMT-5 > > > + Etc/GMT-6 > > > + Etc/GMT-7 > > > + Etc/GMT-8 > > > + Etc/GMT-9 > > > + Etc/GMT0 > > > + Etc/Greenwich > > > + Etc/UCT > > > + Etc/UTC > > > + Etc/Universal > > > + Etc/Zulu > > > Europe/Amsterdam > > > Europe/Andorra > > > Europe/Athens > > > + Europe/Belfast > > > Europe/Belgrade > > > Europe/Berlin > > > + Europe/Bratislava > > > Europe/Brussels > > > Europe/Bucharest > > > Europe/Budapest > > > *************** > > > *** 232,269 **** > > > --- 418,477 ---- > > > Europe/Copenhagen > > > Europe/Dublin > > > Europe/Gibraltar > > > + Europe/Guernsey > > > Europe/Helsinki > > > + Europe/Isle_of_Man > > > Europe/Istanbul > > > + Europe/Jersey > > > Europe/Kaliningrad > > > Europe/Kiev > > > Europe/Lisbon > > > + Europe/Ljubljana > > > Europe/London > > > Europe/Luxembourg > > > Europe/Madrid > > > Europe/Malta > > > + Europe/Mariehamn > > > Europe/Minsk > > > Europe/Monaco > > > Europe/Moscow > > > + Europe/Nicosia > > > Europe/Oslo > > > Europe/Paris > > > + Europe/Podgorica > > > Europe/Prague > > > Europe/Riga > > > Europe/Rome > > > Europe/Samara > > > + Europe/San_Marino > > > + Europe/Sarajevo > > > Europe/Simferopol > > > + Europe/Skopje > > > Europe/Sofia > > > Europe/Stockholm > > > Europe/Tallinn > > > Europe/Tirane > > > + Europe/Tiraspol > > > + Europe/Uzhgorod > > > Europe/Vaduz > > > + Europe/Vatican > > > Europe/Vienna > > > Europe/Vilnius > > > + Europe/Volgograd > > > Europe/Warsaw > > > + Europe/Zagreb > > > + Europe/Zaporozhye > > > Europe/Zurich > > > + GB > > > + GB-Eire > > > GMT > > > + GMT0 > > > + Greenwich > > > HST > > > + Hongkong > > > IET > > > IST > > > + Iceland > > > Indian/Antananarivo > > > Indian/Chagos > > > Indian/Christmas > > > *************** > > > *** 275,290 **** > > > --- 483,516 ---- > > > Indian/Mauritius > > > Indian/Mayotte > > > Indian/Reunion > > > + Iran > > > + Israel > > > JST > > > + Jamaica > > > + Japan > > > + Kwajalein > > > + Libya > > > MET > > > MIT > > > MST > > > + MST7MDT > > > + Mexico/BajaNorte > > > + Mexico/BajaSur > > > + Mexico/General > > > + Mideast/Riyadh87 > > > + Mideast/Riyadh88 > > > + Mideast/Riyadh89 > > > NET > > > NST > > > + NZ > > > + NZ-CHAT > > > + Navajo > > > PLT > > > PNT > > > + PRC > > > PRT > > > PST > > > + PST8PDT > > > Pacific/Apia > > > Pacific/Auckland > > > Pacific/Chatham > > > *************** > > > *** 299,308 **** > > > --- 525,537 ---- > > > Pacific/Guadalcanal > > > Pacific/Guam > > > Pacific/Honolulu > > > + Pacific/Johnston > > > Pacific/Kiritimati > > > Pacific/Kosrae > > > + Pacific/Kwajalein > > > Pacific/Majuro > > > Pacific/Marquesas > > > + Pacific/Midway > > > Pacific/Nauru > > > Pacific/Niue > > > Pacific/Norfolk > > > *************** > > > *** 314,326 **** > > > --- 543,592 ---- > > > Pacific/Port_Moresby > > > Pacific/Rarotonga > > > Pacific/Saipan > > > + Pacific/Samoa > > > Pacific/Tahiti > > > Pacific/Tarawa > > > Pacific/Tongatapu > > > Pacific/Truk > > > Pacific/Wake > > > Pacific/Wallis > > > + Pacific/Yap > > > + Poland > > > + Portugal > > > + ROK > > > SST > > > + Singapore > > > + SystemV/AST4 > > > + SystemV/AST4ADT > > > + SystemV/CST6 > > > + SystemV/CST6CDT > > > + SystemV/EST5 > > > + SystemV/EST5EDT > > > + SystemV/HST10 > > > + SystemV/MST7 > > > + SystemV/MST7MDT > > > + SystemV/PST8 > > > + SystemV/PST8PDT > > > + SystemV/YST9 > > > + SystemV/YST9YDT > > > + Turkey > > > + UCT > > > + US/Alaska > > > + US/Aleutian > > > + US/Arizona > > > + US/Central > > > + US/East-Indiana > > > + US/Eastern > > > + US/Hawaii > > > + US/Indiana-Starke > > > + US/Michigan > > > + US/Mountain > > > + US/Pacific > > > + US/Pacific-New > > > + US/Samoa > > > UTC > > > + Universal > > > VST > > > + W-SU > > > WET > > > + Zulu > > > > > > > >
