I think in general it makes sense to me. Looking at: http://incubator.apache.org/projects/hawq.html I'd like to suggest that perhaps you may want to explicitly ask folks on the committers list whether they wish to remain with the project or not (I suspect some of them will decline the invitation -- but perhaps I'm wrong).
If the list of committers will match the list of PPMC closes -- then I'd also suggest considering making PMC == committers as part of your graduation resolution. Other than that -- I think you will make a great community. Thanks, Roman. On Sat, Apr 28, 2018 at 4:02 AM, 刘奎恩(局外) <kuien....@alibaba-inc.com> wrote: > Great news, I have no reason to reject this wonderful idea. One consideration > is may we have time window to do a bit more efforts on execuation engine? > because these derivative startup projects (hawq+, deepgreen) all claims their > superiority on execuation engine. Maybe, Hawq may co-plan it with Greenplum, > it is one common issue in both data warehouse. > -------------—— > Kuien Liu/奎恩 > ------------------------------------------------------------------发件人：Radar > Lei <r...@pivotal.io>发送时间：2018年4月26日(星期四) 10:16收件人：dev > <dev@hawq.incubator.apache.org>主 题：[DISCUSS] Apache HAWQ Graduation from > Incubator > Hi All, > > With the Apache HAWQ community keep healthy and growing, I think now would > be a good time to discuss where we stand regarding to graduation from the > Incubator, and what requirements remains. > > Apache HAWQ entered incubation in September of 2015, since then, the HAWQ > community learned a lot about how to do things in Apache ways. Now we are a > very helpful and engaged community, ready to help on all questions > from the HAWQ > community. We delivered four releases including two binary releases, now we > can do self-driving releases in good cadence. The community is growing, > new committers and PPMC members keep joining. We addressed the maturity > issues one by one followed by Apache Project Maturity Model [1], currently all > the License and IP issues we can see got resolved. > > Base on those, I believes it's time for us to graduate to TLP. [2] > > Any thoughts? And welcome advice from HAWQ Mentors? > > Thanks, > > [1] https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/HAWQ/ASF+Maturity+Evaluation > [2] https://incubator.apache.org/guides/graduation.html#grad > uating_to_a_top_level_project > > Regards, > Radar
