Thanks for the response. Why would you recommend "fewer than 500" concurrent connections for httpclient. I assume you are talking about high use of resources when not using an asynchronous execution framework such as mine, correct?
Thanks, Jason ----- Original Message ----- From: Oleg Kalnichevski Sent: 06/17/12 10:07 AM To: HttpComponents Project Subject: Re: Akka + httpclient vs httpasyncclient On Sun, 2012-06-17 at 09:16 -0400, Jason Weden wrote: > This week I had the pleasure of wrapping my httpclient.execute() call of httpcomponents httpclient in an akka future. I'm no expert but I think with this and the oncomplete() callback, I made the sending of http requests and receiving of the replies both asynchronous and non-blocking. (I'm using the threadedclientconnmanager and hope to upgrade to poolingconmanager when I move to version 4.2.) > > My question is why not pose this as a solution rather than build httpasyncclient? Httpasyncclient doesn't appear to use akka and so you don't get all the benefits and performance of akka. I am very curious therefore to understand the benefits and drawbacks of my solution vs that of httpasyncclient architecture. Thanks in advance and Happy Fathers Day to the fathers on this list. > > Regards, > > Jason Weden Hi Jason A blocking HTTP client used in conjunction with an asynchronous execution framework such as Akka is a very reasonable ap proach for a lot of applications. However, there are several special types of applications (such as HTTP proxies and gateway) that often have to maintain several thousand outgoing HTTP connections most of which stay idle most of the time. In such a case the cost of context switching of several thousand threads blocked in an I/O operation can become prohibitive. Basically, HttpClient is a general purpose HTTP agent well suited for the majority of applications where the total number of concurrent connections remains relatively low (fewer than 500). HttpAsyncClient is a special purpose HTTP agent primarily intended for HTTP proxies and HTTP gateways that need to maintain over 2000 concurrent connections that stay idle most of the time. Hope this helps somewhat. Oleg PS: Happy Fathers Day! --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]
