On Mon, May 7, 2018 at 12:23 PM, Yann Ylavic <ylavic....@gmail.com> wrote: > Hi Jim, > > thanks for testing! > > I tried your scenario (if understood correctly, see below), and it > seems to work for me. > >> I seem to be having issues with this patch via this scenario: >> >> o Using the balancer-manager, make changes. > > BalancerPersist on, right? > Also, I made changes to balancers/members parameters only, since there > doesn't seem to have a way to add balancers or members via the UI. Is > there a way or do you have scripts/cURLs scenario to do this?
I could add balancer members by setting the growth= parameter appropriately in the first place, and the changes were preserved too after shutdown. > >> o Do a grace restart some times. >> o Make more changes. > > I made changes through balancer-manager still, I think configuration > changes could indeed reset manager changes, but that's expected no (I > think it worked like this before already)? > >> o Now shutdown. >> o Now restart. The changes are erased... >> >> It looks like maybe something to do with the generation number... ?? > > Persisted files don't have a generation number, so it should work.. At > least it worked for me with parameters changes only, same parameters > values before/after shutdown/restart. > > Possibly you could elaborate a bit on the kind of changes issued in > between so that I can reproduce? > > > Regards, > Yann.
