Hi Shiyan, Thanks for starting this discussion.
+1 from my side Some additional thought: - Shall the proposal need at least one +1 vote from PMC? - It would be better to explain what's the meaning of +0 and -1. - In other communities, there is another concept when voting which called: binding and non-binding. Shall we introduce it? Best, Vino Shiyan Xu <[email protected]> 于2019年11月13日周三 上午11:54写道： > Hi all, > > As per the RFC process > https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/HUDI/RFC+Process > > We usually start with an email thread to raise an idea before step 2: > creating an RFC page. > > It'll be good to reach an agreement on how many votes (+1) do we need to > proceed to step 2. > > The idea is not to make it too easy, otherwise it defeats the purpose of > setting step 1, but also not to make the bar too high. > > I would like to propose at least 5 votes (+1) needed to proceed: > - 2 votes from the committers, and > - 3 votes from the community (can be committer or non-committer) > > Consider the growing community, we shall be able to increase the numbers as > deemed necessary. > > Any thoughts? How about 5 votes to pass this meta-voting? :) > > > - Raymond >
