Just following up on Jake Farrell's comment over at [email protected] [1]:
"As for the Github workflows that are starting to be used, I am not a
proponent of them. These workflows are not ideal as they repositories are
not under any Asf control and infra can not help if there are any issues,
its up to the project to take care of its own. Also with the JClouds and
now Usergrid projects using this flow adds a lot of overhead for
initial contributions as they have in the workflow the requirement to
ensure an ICLA are on file for the contributor. Most committers do not have
access to see the status of this. Also since these projects are not working
directly against the primary repository it is up to them to ensure that
committers are the only ones submitting code to the primary repository and
then syncing that code at some point over to the ASF repositories in order
to make a release."
Personally, I think our GitHub workflow works well for our contributor
base, and I don't feel as they committers suffer from exceptionally
burdensome overhead as a result. As far as I'm aware, we're also
covering all the legal bases that we need to cover.
Still: anyone else see any problems with the current review and commit flow?
ap
[1] http://markmail.org/message/r6w7fmjqjg6guxc3