Re: [jira] [Created] (JENA-543) Seq created from resource in another model results in Seq from the wrong model.

[Andy Seaborne]

On 23/09/13 18:15, Claude Warren (JIRA) wrote:
Claude Warren created JENA-543:
----------------------------------
              Summary: Seq created from resource in another model results in 
Seq from the wrong model.
                  Key: JENA-543
                  URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/JENA-543
              Project: Apache Jena
           Issue Type: Bug
           Components: Jena
     Affects Versions: Jena 2.11.0
             Reporter: Claude Warren


Create model 1.
Create a resource in model 1

Create model 2
call Seq s = model2.getSeq( resource )

s.getModel() == model1 is true
s.getModel() == model2 is false

s.getModel() should return model2

A general point here - this is a proposed chnage to the functionality of 
the RDF API.  I tend towards expecting the model to be model m2 but at 
the same time I see that it has been the other way for quite sometime.

Should it be changed or do we accept that it is what it is?

Is is really a matter of javadoc?

There is a hint in:

"""
The Seq is assumed to already exist in the model. If it does not, 
createAlt should be used instead.
"""

        Andy