On 09/11/17 18:24, aj...@apache.org wrote:
Great, thanks!
So folks, is there interest in pursuing this rearrangement of our source
management? I would certainly vote for it.
Great - do you want to take this on and see us through the process?
We'll need a [DISCUSS] I expect to make sure we all know what the VOTE
is really about. I'm not clear what "it" is exactly.
I'm all linked up - 2FA etc, and it can see which repo I have access to.
I use JIRA search and git history more and more to understand what users
are asking about and to trace down bugs.
How does gitbox interact with JIRA? Do we get a nice set of JIRA
comment (obvious existing bug - JIRA isn't markdown so `` and {{}} mess up.
I guess discussion is on GH issues, not JIRA tickets, which is a change
but fine by me.
The "git pull github pull/XXX/head --no-ff ; git push" is clunky but not
the end of the world.
(Unrelated wish - delete of the local branch - is that "git fetch
--prune"?).
> it's not possible to use the Github PR review machinery transparently
This confused me - we use GH PR review at the monent. Could you expand
the point?
So I guess I want to know what changes in the workflows for submission
(nothing presumably but what about JIRA? Auto create-JIRA-on-PR would be
fancy) and for acceptance
I'm expecting changes if we go "gitbox" and that's fine, I'm not arguing
for the status quo. It's not easy to reverse so I want to know what it is.
Andy
https://github.com/apache/jena/blob/master/CONTRIBUTING.md
ajs6f
Daniel Pono Takamori wrote on 11/9/17 1:22 PM:
Gitbox would indeed allow you to have the Github tools available to
committers. It treats Github as the canonical source (we also keep a
copy on Gitbox), which allows the PRs and issues to be a bit more
convenient (there are still some things we can't support due to the
Github's coarse permission structure).
We require all committers to use Github's 2FA [0] so once you have a
taken a vote in the project, file a ticket on the INFRA JIRA [1] and
then your committers can run through the Gitbox syncing [2] to matchup
ASF IDs and Github IDs.
Let us know if you have any other questions.
[0] -
https://help.github.com/articles/providing-your-2fa-authentication-code/
[1] - https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/INFRA
[2] - https://gitbox.apache.org/setup/
On Thu, Nov 9, 2017 at 10:50 AM, <aj...@apache.org> wrote:
Hi, I'm a committer for Jena. Recently, we had some discussion about our
source management and there was some uncertainty about how we can
arrange
the relationship between Github and Apache git.
Currently, commits go against Apache git, and Github picks them up and
mirrors them, which is a bit annoying in that it's not possible to
use the
Github PR review machinery transparently. This is not a big deal, but
is it
in fact possible to do that? In other words, is it possible to (e.g.)
merge
PRs at Github and have Apache git pick up the change?
I went to https://gitbox.apache.org/setup/ and linked my accounts,
but that
didn't seem to do anything...
Thanks for any info!
--
ajs6f
