-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA256 On 3/19/12 11:23 PM, sebb wrote: > On 19 March 2012 20:31, Philippe Mouawad > <philippe.moua...@gmail.com> wrote: >> >> Shall we integrate this sampler: >> >> - https://issues.apache.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=52673 >> >> My opinion regarding it is that as it's difficult to generate >> data usable by this sampler using it will be hard. >> >> So I don't have a definite opinion. > > If it is implemented, why not implement it as an Access Log > Sampler? > > But I agree - I'm not sure it's worth it.
Hey all, if I may comment on this -- if the information in an access log is sufficient for the needs of a test, then the Access Log Sampler is a great deal easier to use. The record/replay scenario is indicated for a test that depends on any of: - - contents of request bodies, such as POST data - - contents of request headers that aren't available from access logs - - reproducing the concurrency of the recorded traffic For that, you need logs of the full contents of requests, either recorded or synthetic. And you're right, that's quite a bit different from just dropping in an access log. So the Replay Sampler certainly wouldn't be used by everyone -- you'd have to be willing and able to do the preparations, for a test that needs it. Whether that's of sufficient interest for the JMeter distribution is a judgment call, but you're welcome to it (since a number of JMeter components are fairly specialized, it didn't seem out of the question). I'll be continuing to maintain it, and would do so in the context of the project. Best, Geoff - -- UPLEX Systemoptimierung Schwanenwik 24 22087 Hamburg http://uplex.de/ Mob: +49-176-63690917 -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG/MacGPG2 v2.0.14 (Darwin) Comment: Using GnuPG with Mozilla - http://enigmail.mozdev.org/ iQIcBAEBCAAGBQJPaEE8AAoJEOUwvh9pJNUR3zMQAIkNvQo1h/su4KpIZIKh10xm LRO7nPa8PoRHyePYvALAQkoiEtqpiwzDUHgonVHHJeSkLJgArC8xPtEt2JgY5VAA keFLkJlL9oUF+DTVAa5fAEv0r3ThFK1LUebKkc2tQJR/0Rv/aAQ3W/tU447pppKU O5m7rC1p2zdA4DUZgEmRwInamD4WoEc7WNRCQDvsvWX8FdezvezGalWsrTKFr5gf zkmdTS89RpEOY5rpolsKxHyoJA0zmZD5pyHUaItYdUTQbAmZ8unCgM7WNAslClMw lQpaOaAcuwTTd6e45YC6tQcXBQtqfqY2T1b6+SPvFEJ2W1PojWwBGmufBb5x0wfR qN2Z4BgxpTsdtluxigshMmoS37XqGZR0RX98/fLkec80kqA8590vMwT0zIRaw1qE wQp8R0tUKXoYRwwr2kkg5MSW5blCfUgiGnJjcE0iPi2TRicXcg2H4mFVTdElf/R5 cf/YPDGw2wAfrdVqreeygHQJqd/omX6ui1kKqTJQl6F4RyoAwxJcc6aDxH5HI6sh kgC9PXlzVVfE49XyuXYIHxMv0jsxfdLfbbkZzgd64EY8H1TyOIXx0A27G07WgiHa QGINBLhI+DJvPiG3NrJE6+Xq43k9lPX4boQna6ifOrLIrKAcTxeJGypxnptnpSMV cx8+ac0l1C7h8aAIh3I3 =jDcM -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
