On Sun, Nov 4, 2012 at 2:09 PM, Milamber <[email protected]> wrote:
> > > Le 03/11/2012 23:47, Shmuel Krakower a ecrit : > > Hi Philippe >> if you concern about performance with the assertion. Maybe as a starter it >> would be better to begin with a separte assertion component for documents? >> Only this one will use Tika and will make it harder for users to mis-use >> Tika when not needed. >> > > There haven't performance issues when JMeter runs a test if the radio > button "Body as a Document" not selected (in Response Assertion or RegExp > extractor) > > Add several new elements (Tika regexp, Tika Assertion) for only one new > radio button in "Response Field to check" section (in current Regexp > extractor and Response Assertion) seems not necessary. > I can add some tooltip on the "Body as a Document" radio button + some > warning in component reference. Seems a good compromise? > > +1 for me. > Milamber > > > > >> Regarding size of JMeter, it shouldn't be a concern. >> >> Overall sounds like a nice upgrade to JMeter capabilities. >> >> Best, >> Shmuel. >> בתאריך 2012 11 3 22:11, מאת "Philippe Mouawad"<philippe.mouawad@** >> gmail.com <[email protected]>>: >> >> Hello Milamber, >>> My answers below. >>> >>> Regards >>> Philippe >>> >>> On Sat, Nov 3, 2012 at 8:23 PM, Milamber<[email protected]> wrote: >>> >>> Hello, >>>> >>>> Currently, I work to add Apache Tika 1.2 [1] in JMeter to improve >>>> functional tests. >>>> >>>> >>> With Tika, you can extract the text form various documents, like MS >>>> >>> Office >>> >>>> (Word, Excel, PowerPoint 97-2003, 2007-2010 (openxml), OpenOffice >>>> >>> (writer, >>> >>>> calc, impress), HTML, Gz, jar/zip files (list of content), and some >>>> "multimedia" files like mp3, mp4, flv, etc. >>>> >>>> In JMeter, Tika can be used by the View Results Tree to view the text >>>> >>> data >>> >>>> of this files, Regular extractor to catch some text from this files and >>>> Response assertion to assert on the data. >>>> >>>> The inconvenient is: Apache Tika requires a big jar (25Mb) or a lot of >>>> >>> jar >>> >>>> files (see below). With all jars in the binary package, the new size >>>> (for >>>> tgz) is 45 Mb (JMeter 2.8 tgz : 23Mb) >>>> >>>> The question: are you agree to add Tika (and new capability to "extract >>>> text from Document") in JMeter with the new binary size? >>>> >>>> I agree but we should check impact on JMeter performance and if it's >>> important warn clearly about it and when to use it. >>> >>> >>> Secondary question: what the good way? : 1/ Add only tika-app.jar (which >>>> include all dependencies) [2], or 2/ Add several jar files (tika-core, >>>> tika-parser, etc + dependencies) [3] >>>> >>>> I would see: >>>> >>> - Tika (core + modules) if available >>> - Dependencies >>> >>> But not Tika+dependencies in one JAR. >>> If first option not possible, reference all tika modules + dependencies >>> >>> >>> Milamber >>>> >>>> >>>> [1] http://tika.apache.org/ >>>> >>>> [2] One Jar : >>>> +tika-app.version = 1.2 >>>> +tika-app.jar = tika-app-${tika-app.version}.****jar >>>> +tika-app.loc = ${maven2.repo}/org/apache/** >>>> tika/tika-app/${tika-app.****version} >>>> +tika-app.md5 = e0ec70c80a6f3b113d8ac1c12a3333****8f >>>> >>>> [3] Several Jars (i must check if jar is missing) >>>> >>>> +tika-core.version = 1.2 >>>> +tika-core.jar = tika-core-${tika-core.version}** >>>> **.jar >>>> +tika-core.loc = ${maven2.repo}/org/apache/** >>>> tika/tika-core/${tika-core.****version} >>>> +tika-core.md5 = 17cfec5a9b28b323375de0692ce5ec** >>>> **b1 >>>> + >>>> +tika-parsers.version = 1.2 >>>> +tika-parsers.jar = tika-parsers-${tika-parsers.** >>>> version}.jar >>>> +tika-parsers.loc = ${maven2.repo}/org/apache/** >>>> tika/tika-parsers/${tika-****parsers.version} >>>> +tika-parsers.md5 = a15b071726358fd195d5c4b0625cdf** >>>> **b5 >>>> + >>>> + >>>> +tika-parsers.version = 1.2 >>>> +tika-parsers.jar = tika-parsers-${tika-parsers.** >>>> version}.jar >>>> +tika-parsers.loc = ${maven2.repo}/org/apache/** >>>> tika/tika-parsers/${tika-****parsers.version} >>>> +tika-parsers.md5 = a15b071726358fd195d5c4b0625cdf** >>>> **b5 >>>> + >>>> +netcdf.version = 4.2-min >>>> +netcdf.jar = netcdf-${netcdf.version}.jar >>>> +netcdf.loc = ${maven2.repo}/edu/ucar/** >>>> netcdf/${netcdf.version} >>>> +netcdf.md5 = eb00b40b0511f0fc1dfcfc9cb89e3c****53 >>>> + >>>> +apache-mime4j-core.version = 0.7.2 >>>> +apache-mime4j-core.jar = >>>> >>> apache-mime4j-core-${apache-* >>> >>>> *mime4j-core.version}.jar >>>> +apache-mime4j-core.loc = >>>> ${maven2.repo}/org/apache/** >>>> james/apache-mime4j-core/${****apache-mime4j-core.version} >>>> +apache-mime4j-core.md5 = >>>> >>> 88f799546eca803c53eee01a4ce5ed >>> >>>> **cd >>>> + >>>> +apache-mime4j-dom.version = 0.7.2 >>>> +apache-mime4j-dom.jar = >>>> apache-mime4j-dom-${apache-** >>>> mime4j-dom.version}.jar >>>> +apache-mime4j-dom.loc = ${maven2.repo}/org/apache/** >>>> james/apache-mime4j-dom/${****apache-mime4j-dom.version} >>>> +apache-mime4j-dom.md5 = >>>> >>> dedc747b5c367fbd7f8a7235d1d7cb >>> >>>> **ee >>>> + >>>> +commons-compress.version = 1.4.1 >>>> +commons-compress.jar = commons-compress-${commons-** >>>> compress.version}.jar >>>> +commons-compress.loc = ${maven2.repo}/org/apache/** >>>> commons/commons-compress/${****commons-compress.version} >>>> +commons-compress.md5 = >>>> >>> 7f7ff9255a831325f38a170992b700*** >>> >>>> *73 >>>> + >>>> +pdfbox.version = 1.7.0 >>>> +pdfbox.jar = pdfbox-${pdfbox.version}.jar >>>> +pdfbox.loc = ${maven2.repo}/org/apache/** >>>> pdfbox/pdfbox/${pdfbox.****version} >>>> +pdfbox.md5 = da9ff2f1b43dc92b15fe3ba39a1cdd****cd >>>> + >>>> +fontbox.version = 1.7.0 >>>> +fontbox.jar = fontbox-${fontbox.version}.jar >>>> +fontbox.loc = ${maven2.repo}/org/apache/** >>>> pdfbox/fontbox/${fontbox.****version} >>>> +fontbox.md5 = 9e03f94d92af257facb148c138af22****fa >>>> + >>>> +jempbox.version = 1.7.0 >>>> +jempbox.jar = jempbox-${jempbox.version}.jar >>>> +jempbox.loc = ${maven2.repo}/org/apache/** >>>> pdfbox/jempbox/${jempbox.****version} >>>> +jempbox.md5 = 69dfbd6872c29f89a4df1179dd54b4****4e >>>> + >>>> +poi.version = 3.8 >>>> +poi.jar = poi-${poi.version}.jar >>>> +poi.loc = ${maven2.repo}/org/apache/poi/**** >>>> poi/${poi.version} >>>> +poi.md5 = 5c915f48922046c71121fd7021aa23****cb >>>> + >>>> +poi-scratchpad.version = 3.8 >>>> +poi-scratchpad.jar = poi-scratchpad-${poi-** >>>> scratchpad.version}.jar >>>> +poi-scratchpad.loc = ${maven2.repo}/org/apache/poi/ >>>> **** >>>> poi-scratchpad/${poi-****scratchpad.version} >>>> +poi-scratchpad.md5 = 7427b6b9e53dcee57d382ba022efc3 >>>> **** >>>> be >>>> + >>>> +poi-ooxml.version = 3.8 >>>> +poi-ooxml.jar = poi-ooxml-${poi-ooxml.version}** >>>> **.jar >>>> +poi-ooxml.loc = ${maven2.repo}/org/apache/poi/**** >>>> poi-ooxml/${poi-ooxml.version} >>>> +poi-ooxml.md5 = 8f147b248f078799c24c8714f185b1** >>>> **a8 >>>> + >>>> +geronimo-stax-api_1.0_spec.****version = 1.0.1 >>>> +geronimo-stax-api_1.0_spec.****jar = >>>> geronimo-stax-api_1.0_spec-${****geronimo-stax-api_1.0_spec.**** >>>> version}.jar >>>> +geronimo-stax-api_1.0_spec.****loc = >>>> ${maven2.repo}/org/apache/****geronimo/specs/geronimo-stax-**** >>>> api_1.0_spec/${geronimo-stax-****api_1.0_spec.version} >>>> +geronimo-stax-api_1.0_spec.****md5 = >>>> b7c2a715cd3d1c43dc4ccfae426e8e****2e >>>> + >>>> +tagsoup.version = 1.2.1 >>>> +tagsoup.jar = tagsoup-${tagsoup.version}.jar >>>> +tagsoup.loc = ${maven2.repo}/org/ccil/cowan/**** >>>> tagsoup/tagsoup/${tagsoup.****version} >>>> +tagsoup.md5 = ae73a52cdcbec10cd61d9ef22fab59****36 >>>> + >>>> +asm.version = 3.1 >>>> +asm.jar = asm-${asm.version}.jar >>>> +asm.loc = ${maven2.repo}/org/ow2/util/** >>>> asm/asm/${asm.version} >>>> +asm.md5 = b1a36e247bf18fb4da46ce3a54627d****1b >>>> + >>>> +isoparser.version = 1.0-RC-1 >>>> +isoparser.jar = isoparser-${isoparser.version}** >>>> **.jar >>>> +isoparser.loc = ${maven2.repo}/com/googlecode/**** >>>> mp4parser/isoparser/${****isoparser.version} >>>> +isoparser.md5 = b0444fde2290319c9028564c3c3ff1** >>>> **ab >>>> + >>>> +metadata-extractor.version = 2.4.0-beta-1 >>>> +metadata-extractor.jar = >>>> >>> metadata-extractor-${metadata- >>> >>>> **extractor.version}.jar >>>> +metadata-extractor.loc = >>>> >>> ${maven2.repo}/com/drewnoakes/ >>> >>>> **metadata-extractor/${**metadata-**extractor.version} >>>> +metadata-extractor.md5 = >>>> >>> 6e0ad2f0fe78047cb34ec056b39633 >>> >>>> **d3 >>>> + >>>> +boilerpipe.version = 1.1.0 >>>> +boilerpipe.jar = boilerpipe-${boilerpipe.** >>>> version}.jar >>>> +boilerpipe.loc = ${maven2.repo}/de/l3s/** >>>> boilerpipe/boilerpipe/${****boilerpipe.version} >>>> +boilerpipe.md5 = 0616568083786d0f49e2cb07a5d09f** >>>> **e4 >>>> + >>>> +rome.version = 0.9 >>>> +rome.jar = rome-${rome.version}.jar >>>> +rome.loc = ${maven2.repo}/rome/rome/${**** >>>> rome.version} >>>> +rome.md5 = 19589699b01c59ccb4d5e61e4c78b3****11 >>>> + >>>> +vorbis-java-core.version = 0.1 >>>> +vorbis-java-core.jar = vorbis-java-core-${vorbis-** >>>> java-core.version}.jar >>>> +vorbis-java-core.loc = >>>> >>> ${maven2.repo}/org/gagravarr/**** >>> >>>> vorbis-java-core/${vorbis-****java-core.version} >>>> +vorbis-java-core.md5 = >>>> >>> b88115be2754cb6883e652ba68ca46*** >>> >>>> *c8 >>>> + >>>> +juniversalchardet.version = 1.0.3 >>>> +juniversalchardet.jar = juniversalchardet-${** >>>> juniversalchardet.version}.jar >>>> +juniversalchardet.loc = >>>> >>> ${maven2.repo}/com/googlecode/ >>> >>>> **juniversalchardet/****juniversalchardet/${**** >>>> juniversalchardet.version} >>>> +juniversalchardet.md5 = >>>> >>> d9ea0a9a275336c175b343f2e4cd8f >>> >>>> **27 >>>> + >>>> +xz.version = 1.1 >>>> +xz.jar = xz-${xz.version}.jar >>>> +xz.loc = >>>> >>> ${maven2.repo}/org/tukaani/xz/****${xz.version} >>> >>>> +xz.md5 = 4d0ba9643c8f3f7c6721be3a1286da****1c >>>> + >>>> +dom4j.version = 1.6.1 >>>> +dom4j.jar = dom4j-${dom4j.version}.jar >>>> +dom4j.loc = ${maven2.repo}/dom4j/dom4j/${*** >>>> *dom4j.version} >>>> +dom4j.md5 = 4d8f51d3fe3900efc6e395be48030d****6d >>>> + >>>> +xmlbeans.version = 2.6.0 >>>> +xmlbeans.jar = xmlbeans-${xmlbeans.version}.****jar >>>> +xmlbeans.loc = ${maven2.repo}/org/apache/** >>>> xmlbeans/xmlbeans/${xmlbeans.****version} >>>> +xmlbeans.md5 = 6591c08682d613194dacb01e95c78c****2c >>>> + >>>> +poi-ooxml.version = 3.8 >>>> +poi-ooxml.jar = poi-ooxml-${poi-ooxml.version}****.jar >>>> +poi-ooxml.loc = ${maven2.repo}/org/apache/poi/**** >>>> poi-ooxml/${poi-ooxml.version} >>>> +poi-ooxml.md5 = 8f147b248f078799c24c8714f185b1****a8 >>>> + >>>> +poi-ooxml-schemas.version = 3.8 >>>> +poi-ooxml-schemas.jar = poi-ooxml-schemas-${poi-ooxml-* >>>> *** >>>> schemas.version}.jar >>>> +poi-ooxml-schemas.loc = ${maven2.repo}/org/apache/poi/* >>>> *** >>>> poi-ooxml-schemas/${poi-ooxml-****schemas.version} >>>> +poi-ooxml-schemas.md5 = >>>> >>> 7ebcffdc4d82b2b8cbc6464d4543cd****07 >>> >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> >>> -- >>> Cordialement. >>> Philippe Mouawad. >>> >>> > > -- Cordialement. Philippe Mouawad.
