vlsi commented on code in PR #5869: URL: https://github.com/apache/jmeter/pull/5869#discussion_r1186134805
########## src/protocol/http/src/main/java/org/apache/jmeter/protocol/http/proxy/DefaultSamplerCreator.java: ########## @@ -359,18 +361,42 @@ protected void computeSamplerName(HTTPSamplerBase sampler, String prefix = StringUtils.defaultString(request.getPrefix(), ""); int httpSampleNameMode = request.getHttpSampleNameMode(); String format = getFormat(httpSampleNameMode, request.getHttpSampleNameFormat()); + String url = null; + try { + url = sampler.getUrl().toString(); + } catch (MalformedURLException e) { + url = "MALFORMED-URL"; + log.warn("Could not get URL to name sample", e); + } + List<Object> values = Arrays.asList( + prefix, + sampler.getPath(), + sampler.getMethod(), + sampler.getDomain(), + sampler.getProtocol(), + sampler.getPort(), + url + ); + Object[] valuesArray; if (!HTTPConstants.CONNECT.equals(request.getMethod()) && isNumberRequests()) { - sampler.setName(MessageFormat.format(format, prefix, sampler.getPath(), incrementRequestNumberAndGet())); + valuesArray = values.toArray(new Object[values.size() + 1]); + valuesArray[values.size()] = incrementRequestNumberAndGet(); } else { - sampler.setName(MessageFormat.format(format, prefix, sampler.getPath())); + valuesArray = values.toArray(); } + sampler.setName(MessageFormat.format(format,valuesArray)); } private String getFormat(int httpSampleNameMode, String format) { if (httpSampleNameMode == SAMPLER_NAME_NAMING_MODE_FORMATTER) { return format.replaceAll("#\\{name([,}])", "{0$1") .replaceAll("#\\{path([,}])", "{1$1") - .replaceAll("#\\{counter([,}])", "{2$1"); + .replaceAll("#\\{method([,}])", "{2$1") + .replaceAll("#\\{host([,}])", "{3$1") + .replaceAll("#\\{scheme([,}])", "{4$1") + .replaceAll("#\\{port([,}])", "{5$1") + .replaceAll("#\\{url([,}])", "{6$1") + .replaceAll("#\\{counter([,}])", "{7$1"); Review Comment: In theory, users might have used `{2}` in their scripts for "counter", and if we move counter to `{7}` that would break their scripts. I wonder if we can keep `#{counter}` at position `{2}` even thought that was not properly documented. ########## src/protocol/http/src/main/java/org/apache/jmeter/protocol/http/proxy/DefaultSamplerCreator.java: ########## @@ -359,18 +361,42 @@ protected void computeSamplerName(HTTPSamplerBase sampler, String prefix = StringUtils.defaultString(request.getPrefix(), ""); int httpSampleNameMode = request.getHttpSampleNameMode(); String format = getFormat(httpSampleNameMode, request.getHttpSampleNameFormat()); + String url = null; + try { + url = sampler.getUrl().toString(); + } catch (MalformedURLException e) { + url = "MALFORMED-URL"; + log.warn("Could not get URL to name sample", e); + } + List<Object> values = Arrays.asList( + prefix, + sampler.getPath(), + sampler.getMethod(), + sampler.getDomain(), + sampler.getProtocol(), + sampler.getPort(), + url + ); + Object[] valuesArray; if (!HTTPConstants.CONNECT.equals(request.getMethod()) && isNumberRequests()) { - sampler.setName(MessageFormat.format(format, prefix, sampler.getPath(), incrementRequestNumberAndGet())); + valuesArray = values.toArray(new Object[values.size() + 1]); + valuesArray[values.size()] = incrementRequestNumberAndGet(); } else { - sampler.setName(MessageFormat.format(format, prefix, sampler.getPath())); + valuesArray = values.toArray(); } + sampler.setName(MessageFormat.format(format,valuesArray)); } private String getFormat(int httpSampleNameMode, String format) { if (httpSampleNameMode == SAMPLER_NAME_NAMING_MODE_FORMATTER) { return format.replaceAll("#\\{name([,}])", "{0$1") .replaceAll("#\\{path([,}])", "{1$1") - .replaceAll("#\\{counter([,}])", "{2$1"); + .replaceAll("#\\{method([,}])", "{2$1") + .replaceAll("#\\{host([,}])", "{3$1") + .replaceAll("#\\{scheme([,}])", "{4$1") + .replaceAll("#\\{port([,}])", "{5$1") + .replaceAll("#\\{url([,}])", "{6$1") + .replaceAll("#\\{counter([,}])", "{7$1"); Review Comment: In theory, users might have used `{2}` in their scripts for "counter", and if we move counter to `{7}` that would break their scripts. I wonder if we can keep `#{counter}` at position `{2}` even though that was not properly documented. -- This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service. To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the URL above to go to the specific comment. To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscr...@jmeter.apache.org For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at: us...@infra.apache.org