Hi David,

I'm not sure to follow you. bootFeatures property defines which features are started at Karaf bootstrap time. It allows user to start a fresh Karaf instance with a set of Karaf features loaded and installed.

For instance, in ServiceMix, we have:
- nmr feature as boot feature and we ship all required jar (using features-add-to-repo goal) in the system OBR - camel-nmr, cxf-nmr, etc are part of the NMR features but not in the boot features set. As we consider this kind of features as optional, we don't ship the features jar in the system OBR

Regards
JB

On 04/16/2011 08:32 AM, David Jencks wrote:
I am wondering why we have boot features in trunk.  In particular I think there 
is an inconsistency around the management feature which is in the minimal boot 
feature list and whose jars are in the minimal server assembly.  On the other 
hand the ssh full boot feature doesn't have all its jars in the full server.

If a boot feature doesn't already have all its jars in the server, won't this 
require internet access on initial startup?

If all the jars for a boot feature are already installed in the server, why 
call it a boot feature, why not just start it with the rest of the jars?  For 
this question I may be biased by looking at the packaging based assemblies 
where the startup.properties is constructed from the features that are 
installed into the server, so it is at least as east to configure the assembly 
to just include the jars as to configure a boot feature.

Am I missing something?

thanks
david jencks



Reply via email to