+1 On 2024/09/12 16:22:22 ricardo zanini fernandes wrote: > Hi everyone, > > After a few weeks of discussing and experimenting with Tiago Bento, we > reached a point where we are comfortable sharing that the experiment of > permanently having `kogito-images` and `kogito-serverless-operator` inside > `kie-tools` has received positive feedback from the people who usually > develop these modules. This new proposal targets `main` (I.e., Apache KIE > 10.1 and beyond), so Apache KIE 10.0 is unaffected. > > To be clear, this proposal invalidates the previous agreement we had on > “Unblocking and releasing Apache KIE 10” [1], of removing > `sonataflow-devmode-image`, `sonataflow-builder-image`, and > `sonataflow-operator` from `kie-tools` once Apache KIE 10.0 is released. > (See this PR https://github.com/apache/incubator-kie-tools/pull/2472.) > > The infrastructure `kie-tools` provides is suitable for continuing to > develop and release Kogito Images and the SonataFlow Operator. The CI > system and PR checks in place worked well and with reasonable performance, > and there were no big disruptions for local development and further > maintenance. > > This proposal includes: > - Permanently move each image from `kogito-images` and the content of > `kogito-serverless-operator` as individual packages on `kie-tools`, > preserving commit history (essentially the same move we did for Apache KIE > 10, but now for all images) > > - Write and publish a “KIE Tools User Manual” as a markdown file on > `kie-tools` itself > > - Adapting release scripts for publishing the “new” images from `kie-tools` > instead of from `kogito-images`. > > - Permanently archive `kogito-images` and `kogito-serverless-operator`, > removing them from all Jenkins and GitHub Actions automations > > All Kogito Images and the SonataFlow Operator will then depend on the > timestamped SNAPSHOT version of upstream projects (automatically published > every Sunday night or on demand) and will be in sync at all times with the > rest of the `kie-tools` repository, meaning the SonataFlow Quarkus Dev UI, > Serverless Logic Web Tools as a whole, and the SonataFlow Knative Plugin > (CLI). > > By creating a package for each “new” Kogito Image, all PR checks and the CI > will work, requiring zero changes to the existing automations. > > We believe this improves our codebase structure and, more importantly, our > release automations, with minimal disruption to those contributing to those > packages. > > Since some of the `sonataflow-builder-image`, the > `sonataflow-devmode-image`, and the `sonataflow-operator` packages were > already moved to the `main` branch of `kie-tools` as a temporary solution > for unblocking and releasing Apache KIE 10, if this proposal is approved, > we’d need to override the existing packages, bringing with commit history > and in a permanent fashion. The execution plan of this proposal is as > follows: > 1. Push the finalized version of a “KIE Tools User Guide” as a markdown > file hosted on `kie-tools` itself > > 2. Push new packages for each “new” Kogito Image override the existing > `sonataflow-builder-image`, `sonataflow-devmode-image`, and > `sonataflow-operator`, with commit history > > 3. Adapt existing packages on `kie-tools` to depend on and consume the new > ones > > 4. Change release scripts on `kie-tools` to publish the “new” images from it > > 5. Remove `kogito-images` and `kogito-serverless-operator` from GitHub > Actions and Jenkins automations > > 6. Archive `kogito-images` and `kogito-serverless-operator` on GitHub, > changing their README to communicate the change > > 7. Update documentation references to reflect the change on repo URLs etc > > Lastly, if this proposal is approved, further optimizations will be done to > ensure the code is more robust, PR checks are faster and consume less > resources: > > 1. Stop building kogito-apps modules during Kogito Images build (pull from > Maven instead, based on the the timestamped SNAPSHOT version) > > 2. Convert the SonataFlow Knative Plugin (CLI) from a package to a module > inside the SonataFlow Operator package > > 3. Reduce the size of serverless-logic-web-tools-swf-dev-mode-image > (currently at 1.68GB on Docker Hub) > > 4. Parameterize Quarkus version on Kogito Images, SonataFlow Operator and > Knative Plugin (CLI) based on the `kie-tools`’s Quarkus version > > Please let me know, > > Regards, > > [1] https://lists.apache.org/thread/58xm7pqdyztf7qztmhvntf8wdmvfx7jx > > -- > Ricardo Zanini Fernandes > Vida longa e próspera. >
--------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscr...@kie.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: dev-h...@kie.apache.org
