Hi Tibor, Paolo, my personal view is that the quarkus/springboot boms should be placed inside kogito-runtimes repository itself, and everything quarkus-related should be moved from drools-repo to kogito-runtimes. One of the goals IMO is to completely "clean-up" drools repository from any framework-related dependency, and move the framework integration inside kogito-runtimes. Does this make sense ?
Il giorno mar 29 lug 2025 alle ore 11:06 Tibor Zimányi <tzima...@apache.org> ha scritto: > Hi Paolo, > > thank you for this initiative. It is really needed, however I think it > needs to be done on the whole KIE level, not just Drools level. The same > situation is in kogito-runtimes repository. Therefore I think we need a > global KIE bom and then global Quarkus bom and global Spring Boot bom. > > What do you think, please? > > Best regards, > Tibor > > > Dňa ut 29. 7. 2025, 10:54 Paolo Bizzarri <pibi...@gmail.com> napísal(a): > > > Hi, > > > > this discussion comes after the concerns expressed by Gabriele in this > > comment on this PR. > > > > > > > https://github.com/apache/incubator-kie-drools/pull/6352#issuecomment-2911439196 > > > > I want to address Gabriele's main points: > > > > - keep Drools as much as possible separated from frameworks like Quarkus > > and Springboot > > - provide separate BOMs for Quarkus Extension and Springboot Extension. > > > > The idea is to have three BOMs - one for simple Drools projects, one for > > projects that use Droos + Quarkus and one for projects that use Drools + > > SpringBoot. > > > > In this way if a project needs just Drools it could use only the Drools > > BOM, while a project that wants to use also Quarkus would have to use the > > Drools + Quarkus BOM. > > > > This is a breaking change however - projects that want to use Drools + > > Quarkus will have to use a different BOM. We can address this in the > > release notes. > > > > I expect the complexity of this change to be minimal, and I am going to > > take care of it. > > > > Let me know your opinion. > > > > Regards > > > > P. > > >
