Michael Wechner schrieb: > Andreas Hartmann wrote: > >> Hi Jonathan, >> >> Jonathan Addison schrieb: >> >> >>> Hi Andreas, >>> >>> Thanks for this fix. IIUC this should remove any menu entries from >>> these module and resource type declarations from the child >>> publication. They are still showing in my pub though. Is there >>> anything else I need >>> to update? >>> >> >> actually they should still appear, since modules and resource types are >> inherited, see http://issues.apache.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=39899 >> >> It looks like we have two conflicting requirements here. >> >> What do the others think? > > I am not sure if I really understand what the conflict is. > Can you explain a bit more?
Jörn filed a bug that "publications should inherit modules and resource types from their template" (39899). I agree to that and implemented it, therefore it is not necessary anymore that the instantiator copies the resource type and module declarations from the parent to the child. IIUC Jonathan doesn't agree to this, he wants that the menu items of the parent modules don't appear in the child publication. Please correct me if I'm wrong. IMO this could lead to inconsistencies - if the child publication can't access the modules of the parent publication, the functionality might be endangered. -- Andreas --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
