Quoting Dmitri Gabinski <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>:

> Dear Laci,
>
> >Fortunatelly, it's not too late to fix. I compare and update Hunspell
> > with Myspell of OOo 2.0 beta till Wednesday.
>
> HOL VAN AZ UPDATE? WHERE IS THE UPDATE?
>
> Best regards,

Dear Dmitri,

Glad to see your friendly question. :)

I have fixed some really bugs in Hunspell, thanks for your nice
bug report. I have also improved the ngram suggestion with
ALLCAP suggestion (siggraph's -> SIGGRAPH's) and not neighboring
swap character suggestion (pernament -> permanent).
I'm almost finished Hunspell 1.1.0.

My comments:

> A)
> All languages: HunSpell produces much less suggestions for
> misspelled words. And that means, that in some occasions you don't
> find a variant you'd want to use.
> Here's one example in Russian. Instead of
â&#65533;&#65533;ФиŃ&#65533;Паâ&#65533;&#65533;
(â&#65533;&#65533;Firmâ&#65533;&#65533;, >
â&#65533;&#65533;Companyâ&#65533;&#65533;)
> I write â&#65533;&#65533;ФŃ&#65533;иПаâ&#65533;&#65533;.
> HunSpell suggests for that case:
> Đ&#65533;Ń&#65533;иПа
> Đ&#65533;Ń&#65533;иПа
> Đ&#65533;Ń&#65533;иПа
> Obviously, none of that variants is what I need.

I have missed your bug report in my respond. This was obviously
not ngram related problem, but a really bug (lost suggestions).
I have fixed it.

> B) Russian: HunSpell ignores the letter
> â&#65533;&#65533;Ń&#65533;â&#65533;&#65533;. One explanation: that
> letter is not obligatory in the modern Russian orthography and many
> people normally use â&#65533;&#65533;Đľâ&#65533;&#65533; instead. I am among
> those that insist on using
> â&#65533;&#65533;Ń&#65533;â&#65533;&#65533; and I have the ru_RU_yo.* module
> for Russian in OOo. Again, one
> simple example: I edit a text with
> â&#65533;&#65533;Đľâ&#65533;&#65533;-spelling
> and have, say, â&#65533;&#65533;ооâ&#65533;&#65533;
> instead of â&#65533;&#65533;ĐľŃ&#65533;â&#65533;&#65533; that I prefer.
> â&#65533;&#65533;ооâ&#65533;&#65533; is marked as error and MySpell
> suggests â&#65533;&#65533;ĐľŃ&#65533;â&#65533;&#65533; among other variants.
> HunSpell does not. Can it be
> connected with the fact that the Russian module is based on the KOI-8
> encoding?

In OOo 1.1.4, Myspell suggests max. 15 suggestions. MySpell 3.2
in beta OOo does max. 25 suggestions. The preferred suggestion
(&#1077;&#1105;) is the last one! I think, instead of huge number of
suggestions we need a more user friendly approach. Using MAP definition
is the preferred way here:

MAP 1
MAP &#1077;&#1105;

ru_RU_yo example using this MAP definition:

Hunspell 1.0.9
& &#1077;&#1077; 15 0: &#1077;&#1105;, &#1088;&#1077;&#1077;,
&#1083;&#1077;&#1077;, &#1096;&#1077;&#1077;, &#1092;&#1077;&#1077;,
&#1077;&#1088;&#1077;, &#1077;&#1083;&#1077;, &#1077;&#1076;&#1077;,
&#1077;&#1078;&#1077;, &#1090;&#1077;, &#1085;&#1077;, &#1088;&#1077;,
&#1087;&#1077;, &#1076;&#1077;, &#1078;&#1077;
&
&#1090;&#1088;&#1077;&#1093;&#1074;&#1077;&#1076;&#1077;&#1088;&#1085;&#1099;&#1081;
2 0:
&#1090;&#1088;&#1105;&#1093;&#1074;&#1077;&#1076;&#1105;&#1088;&#1085;&#1099;&#1081;,
&#1090;&#1088;&#1105;&#1093;&#1074;&#1105;&#1076;&#1077;&#1088;&#1085;&#1099;&#1081;


C) Belarusian: HunSpell counts words at sentence beginning (i.e., with
the first letter capitalized) as errors and suggests lowercase-only
spellings. That's not acceptable.

There was problem also in KOI8-U and microsoft-cp1251 cyrillic encodings
in Hunspell. Am I right, that Belarusian modul uses one of the two encodings?

Thanks.

Laci




>
> Dmitri Gabinski
>
> ---
> Ďđîäóęöč˙ ôčđě "CAMPINGAZ" č "COLEMAN" îďňîě č â đîçíčöó. Íŕäóâíűĺ ęđîâŕňč,
> đĺřĺňęč-ăđčëü, ňĺđěîńóěęč č ňĺđěîęîíňĺéíĺđű, ăŕçîâîĺ îáîđóäîâŕíčĺ, ďŕëŕňęč,
> ńďŕëüíčęč č ěí.äđ. http://www.TURIZM.shop.by , ă.Ěčíńę, óë.Äđîçäŕ 6.
>
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
> For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
>
>




----------------------------------------------------------------
This message was sent using IMP, the Internet Messaging Program.

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to