Hi Sam,

>
> /* Compiz plugin 'group'
>  *
>  * group.cpp
>  *
>  * Copyright (c) 2010 The OpenCompositing Foundation
>  * Authors: Danny Baumann [general idea] <email>
>  *                Dennis Kasprzyk [nice animations] <email>
>  *                Patrick Nikalaus [cairoization] <email>
>  *                Roi Cohen [cairoization] <email>
>  *                Sam Spilsbury [ported to compiz 0.9] <email>
>  *
>  * This code is licenced under the GPL v2 blah blah blah
>  */
>

I hope you didn't use the real copyright header. ;-)

> What this does in effect is grant a copyright licence to 'The
> OpenCompositing Foundation' which is to be run by the Compiz Council.
> I feel that this would be effective in case we ever needed to change
> the licence of our code since what the project has found is that a lot
> of past developers have dropped out-of-contact. This means that trying
> to change the licence or any legal issues pertaining to the copyright
> of the code could become a lot more difficult if those developers
> cannot be contacted for any reason - especially if a decision is made
> with the licence of the code that they do not agree to retroactively.
>

How often do we intend to change the license anyway? Sure, it would be
better to have a organization that could handle legal conflicts, but
I'm not sure whether that this is really needed for a project of this
scope.
Transferring your copyrights to a foundation is not really easy
either. It requires a signed contract that must be delivered by mail
(note the missing e) and we would need someone to collect them and
store them safely.

>
> The OpenCompositing Foundation [or whatever we want to call it] would
> be run the Compiz Council as it stands - which should be re-elected at
> certain time-periods to reflect the people who are really running the
> show [As I'll address in my next mail to the list]
>

Creating such a foundation is not really straight forward. First of
all, our developers or former-developers are scattered all over the
world. We would need to choose a specific country for this foundation
and depending on the local law the administration of such a foundation
is not trivial. For example KDE is a e.V., the German version of a non
profit foundation. The German law it rather specific when it comes to
regulations of this organizations. For example you need at least 7
people (present at the first meeting) to create such a e.V. and you
need to pass internal rules and elect a committee etc. I'm not sure
how complicated this is in the US, but probably we would need legal
assistance in form of a lawyer. Thus, I think creating a own
foundation is not really an option, unless a significant amount of
people are willing to spend a lot of time on this.

Regards,
Patrick
_______________________________________________
Dev mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.compiz-fusion.org/mailman/listinfo/dev

Reply via email to