Hi, On Fri, Jan 10, 2014 at 8:09 AM, MyungJoo Ham <[email protected]>wrote:
> > On 2014-01-10, 01:44 +0000, 함명주 wrote: > > > Dear Tizen Developers, > > > > > > Traversing various git repos in tizen.org, we've found that there are > some git > > > repos categorized as "Domain: Base" while the gut feeling of mine says > the git > > > repos belong to another. > > > > > > I'm not yet hereby saying that we need to recategorize them all right > now > > > (those who require immediate attention are already served). > > > > > > However, could somebody provide some definitions or description of the > Domain > > > Base? or put it somewhere such as " > https://review.tizen.org/gerrit/#/admin/ > > > groups/453,info "? > > > > > > First, I thought it as something like GLIBC, the base libraries; > however, it > > > does not seem so with the current list in that domain. > > > > > > It even confuse me further with kernel related repos. > > > > > > > toolchain and everything need for a base system to boot up? just my > > guess... > > > > What's your proposal? > > > > /Kangkai > > 1. We need some definitions and description publically available > especially because "BASE" seems not that clear. > Good that you brought this up. Every domain needs to be defined and documented. Perhaps we use https://wiki.tizen.org/wiki/Tizen_Platform_Architecture_Overview page (we need it for the https://wiki.tizen.org/wiki/Platform_Developmenteffort anyway). > 2. So.. what is the "Base System". If it includes everything to boot up, > how does it differ from "System"? For example, is "grep" Base? or System?. > Is "systemd" Base? or System? and so on. > > If it has been meant to be "everything required to boot up", > 2-1. There are things even not falling in that category. > 2-2. There seems to be much overlap between Base and others (esp. System) > 2-3. Toolchain and "base libraries" will be much smaller than that > definition. > > We might end up with almost identical lists of architects, maintainers, > integrators, and reviewers for System and Base if we keep the current > categories. > IMO, Base should be very minimal: just boot to shell and nothing more. A general guideline could be: Base needs to be self sufficient and have no binary RPM dependencies to other domains. -- Mikko
_______________________________________________ Dev mailing list [email protected] https://lists.tizen.org/listinfo/dev
