Given Ralph and Piotr are strongly opinionated about keeping
`log4j-api-3.x` binary compatible to `log4j-api-2.x`, can we not release
`log4j-api-3.x` in `main` and make `main` only depend on `log4j-api-2.x`
instead? (We can move the contents of the `spi` package in `log4j-api-3.x`
to a separate `log4j-spi` module in `main`.) This will make everything
crystal clear:

   - Log4j 3 is just a major improvement over the backend
   - Log4j 3 still supports Log4j 2 API
   - We can move the Log4j 2 API to a separate repository with its own
   release life cycle (ala SLF4J)
   - When time comes to make a new Log4j API where PMC agrees to make
   breaking changes, we can call that one Log4j 3 API

I would appreciate it if you can help me to understand if I am
missing something. Otherwise, I would like to know why we need to make a
major release for a project that is identical to its previous version.

Reply via email to