It shouldn't hold a key you don't trust 100%. Presumably the very old committers are still happy that their keys are in their possession.

On 6/15/10 5:43 AM, Uwe Schindler wrote:
But you still need the public key, to verify the old downloaded artifact. And 
that is I am talking about. Which releases were signed by that key? The keyfile 
is also migrated to We also have the keys of very old committers in it no 
longer active. The keyfile should hold all public keys used to sign any 
previous release available on archive.apache.org!

-----
Uwe Schindler
H.-H.-Meier-Allee 63, D-28213 Bremen
http://www.thetaphi.de
eMail: [email protected]

-----Original Message-----
From: Mark Miller [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Tuesday, June 15, 2010 10:42 AM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: svn commit: r954674 - /lucene/java/dist/KEYS

Yeah, I considered that - but then decided its prob better not to keep it
around. What I'd really like to do is revoke my old key, but I don't have it
anymore and I also don't have the revocation cert to do it.

Technically, the key went out on a laptop (I know to who, and I know its been
reformatted, but I didn't see that happen - and it's since been sold to
someone else).

Unfortunately the Key is on key servers out there, but there is no way to
revoke it that I can find without access to the original revocation cert I made.


- Mark

On 6/15/10 1:50 AM, Uwe Schindler wrote:
Hi Mark,

In my opinion, replacing the key is a bad idea, as now old releases (released
by your old key) cannot be verified anymore. On apache.org is only *one*
version of this file available, that gets replaced on every release - so the old
keys should be persistent. You should add the key to the file.

-----
Uwe Schindler
H.-H.-Meier-Allee 63, D-28213 Bremen
http://www.thetaphi.de
eMail: [email protected]

-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Tuesday, June 15, 2010 1:52 AM
To: [email protected]
Subject: svn commit: r954674 - /lucene/java/dist/KEYS

Author: markrmiller
Date: Mon Jun 14 23:51:57 2010
New Revision: 954674

URL: http://svn.apache.org/viewvc?rev=954674&view=rev
Log:
change my key

Modified:
      lucene/java/dist/KEYS

Modified: lucene/java/dist/KEYS
URL:

http://svn.apache.org/viewvc/lucene/java/dist/KEYS?rev=954674&r1=9546
7
3&r2=954674&view=diff

==========================================================
====================
--- lucene/java/dist/KEYS (original)
+++ lucene/java/dist/KEYS Mon Jun 14 23:51:57 2010
@@ -367,60 +367,60 @@ EXxVbgGadMHBaufCEBm04uU=
   =DT04
   -----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----

-pub   4096R/EB0199F8 2009-09-17
+pub   4096R/78796AC8 2010-06-14
   uid                  Mark Robert Miller (CODE SIGNING KEY)
<[email protected]>
-sub   4096R/3416EB41 2009-09-17
+sub   4096R/1D6080E5 2010-06-14
   -----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
-Version: GnuPG v1.4.9 (GNU/Linux)
+Version: GnuPG v1.4.10 (GNU/Linux)

-

mQINBEqyuXMBEACiggnOjvAXi6x+idSmFvAWP9HPIoLYIGMBoeKwvPep+1O
ZzAeF
-

c4Y8i3Fv3hQQk5jazuQ3UPUeoaEZoYrlHh6MNC57qsFklk9EICuZXMkuq6WiFzt
d
-

hzdRu3LmXndSAVNU6VjNWy/d8EUtGnsfl74VYghBtWNqtvIBZTnHT+FE9srQ/
mue
-
rFkRRaIvjUjABJfJOOhuKxnK4aMcTpf3JFvPLPto6L1gj95DkO/yCcTKEEO+/M9i
-

605fwQN7uP5OJ/PIlMff60xIyy3BU8Olk2856gdiDKoUM2W6/cA/db8F+8ZukAS
r
-

zCbwfvKr2hvFgoBR2nXlRE6xfWD0TuoyIDQ81MSZJE7fz8qg4LWuSQTnl7dMKU
RR
-

3vvwVTB2UWnkwuCvxKD4XYIsC5TgAVKLyBd6gYtYhXtsflCdy/+gCh3wDcmtLO
nd
-

ZzUQiDy157+PGXzsOrgR1RrWIXtyTKwI2PBIlPIpdtJ8DE0B3EqsO2RVP0MUgqu
p
-

V5bRAG3dS653t/io81kg+VBDMBdir8sP+HAKSOr0YS+aZbZQd6RNjsQb4EBWO
o1Q
-

qOcW2gTVePXSuoVf5JVmQbTPJd8UTBXCcYp90cGgfZLEwe5WuMXDxksQMg
XB0xbh
-

Bux8Gh0aXSVBLvVZ/7F40z6Md7arl4NrsQhppTs2K/zajU05oM5Qzks86wARAQ
AB

+mQINBEwWQMQBEADIW2N2SoxK4BKZKvYLlehU66KxVRuYnbdAyORd6cvF
wHuF6pII

+h33sGE31CST0f01HpMB0cuTS+4P03rAf8daj4fB+jYWHOjaMuG55fxYdXKTEf
mSb

+Er+lIyaiFwObguCkFUiFKyJAaYMHxYJLoqvwsb1cXVb8IfNcMQHI4jGq+r1oVTl
Z

+kYpkUvEAy7SpMlVgvdoRUO6pWtBHWBIbtAlbKwHWxrWrA+Mn5Lqc8OiUEJ
2oYrxs

+ZW8qtpDJ6LEzTurrSB6CKOUzC7VP7kE1iY+X9WEL1CCorpwo3Nk5jhW7YoiIuZ
eZ
+rMIiybE26n+OivsTC5ICPis06+5qN/63uiBe9D30/cSStfysZZZXU6vfkkQ134if

+XuLEuygrPPHc4Zr1zLgoAQ+TzV/nfi+YmURAyYnXsI7wPERaFUfoCcA2OqDHH
yZV

+Mrg13ZmIVTzSv/F8slqWh+4Yy8hFUHxflnxN34wyGTHX0aAE+copRXx0aY1bh
bA+

+Im54zvltOIPKH5/Av7h8H0R3iLaT44fe9g5tDkuJf8ACUukmyYIPX/PZjJTr41lw

+qo6Z0ke+5fcndX82QQHkhHAQSk85gcgvAZOtHJ9zadrK1uUnoS3HRQPa3Qu
MKMMS

+RyOuqx3POEfX9N0hrY3eQFSn2T8szzDt6VMTmpF57/yA9jbvZyiXkWVITwAR
AQAB


tD5NYXJrIFJvYmVydCBNaWxsZXIgKENPREUgU0lHTklORyBLRVkpIDxtYXJrcm1
p
-

bGxlckBhcGFjaGUub3JnPokCNwQTAQoAIQUCSrK5cwIbAwULCQgHAwUVCg
kICwUW
-

AgMBAAIeAQIXgAAKCRATBZhM6wGZ+ODWEACFsyAhi0mvW13ch87M32UI
wskr9rQV
-

xfn/1Pgsrn+QSSxPY5ia1R/zWqHH1soRShteN0Ptuq+EIeX/1aI+wHI0ONgV8AQ
u
-

Cvx1Xpc9MKrtU0E1e+qHRhI4DVLptpRHb0SHx11wnQkg0DccA81Q1A43sp9/er
Nn
-

UGiacf+vaKj4UB+AzZtH8gtM+KLCr8COPIBlVAC+JKRNC2oYdUa6OhIvUT8dyA
m2
-

Ri5+Fu68qM/g58XglJ3vZF9xJj6etyK0PY2MAmzvvzJw4ZZc77dxXi6NIUOhvMPK
-

jop22L5PP7NwSRI1wQsfN1NQAHlgkRlQxsGRsUaXGIDnP+aD913qPNztQv2tNs
1c
-

a2ZnvRj3ekSe9sqnsoP9pCCkL9KLenEytB2cHjWM75J8mGu3o+3W7xDFgOrjle
Oc
-

0If4FKACW6VBYa3o6Vfb2bHWsubLT+mIXGRvFuuRlGki7+w6nFFinP7zM5V+5c
RF
-

akhaNSThx3wF/FgU33adXt95wPa7pT8rfQAv49ULUu0CBe2j+rjgOY2Ws21jRPb
r
-
pDOX6hJ0cLKlzvJ4URlkuei1Qp0pBgdmSnESnkLGmz3GTlSlSMCrS1ZJU6lM4iKk
-

+cdRX4sP3IXFkr9VyPzQUs033oQgtX82fcp6p4mHD/P/J406qqI5vA9CiSn4WUw
G
-

CdBE3qDLVWB/v7kCDQRKsrlzARAAr7P8qfBkKNnQk+au6cwbvI3HaXOJB6KSw
VJZ
-
P01CIiTxTfvun7+RIFtzP7tLb/MKcnuX1LW9862CIGa8/I8NWtq+X6CdZsapZ9bE
-

LZq+qWnpoPD1sqsYCgBUUgNQkdHVYFHjvmwBD5s1K7hKCJm7bWxZLBZdQ
m+0b+ZX
-

dzMnzFBaxaS0Mlv7b6Ar4srEtYTa5GXHAY2iXtsV3NXrRX9fs53nGDpiebWPZf1/
-
XgrNHFH9TDXaioMU42YWztEo6NLvPBuKYTpl8EjscD51tZkzc4zbIdOD3fEi+KjP
-
88Zl60d+DciSaRz5zcl8ZkX9bxy53K5aRf3n8fFKVKzbdyEWQyu+hJCnQwCzHgSy
-

pdA7P2C/tv24FIqkMBecEjj01fN4sZ1EmDEdqq6FYz/dsHNT4DEcJrZMMGx8kEq
3
-

WipoV8wwsW5ZGotnGgTpY4t/Yc3bE0CgpEmlM0aJUvqLijZWue0ncPtxf4aoYB
cE
-

nJngjc3qnLJZ1r5B1j62BPQrU6KfkwDcKWnm4amikXndgOodBQt4/fyOBs4vH+b
G
-

mNSrQupbLzgM39D6M6/5e63wrsxiBJrvUBLLz1uzs6f16/9kpM0sxhrp2P2baBe
w
-

Wx5PKan4w7A+gVQpPaVe7Ztrjh/HJeo7+ZsT4FM16qsEsgQc0YNTOm+EgmPh
qnhv
-

CYLL3FkAEQEAAYkCHwQYAQoACQUCSrK5cwIbDAAKCRATBZhM6wGZ+KJSD/
wKuP1K
-

xGQuMw1QW2eLadKYWKwGItNVC5j66d+Yfxwkk3aCswudVottYhjJBsmmbT+
01nme
-

S8GgmhJrzbByGvuyLTVqHAWVyt+WToY1nozn0qp9IdicOBYdzKN4ptxKQrlNA
yNV
-

XmnEj6x4+b3FfQanmkF7HxCQdWOqaDaeluhnsrsJ2mTEW9EZeNv+43ZeDJKl8
2X9
-

J1bPQb+6GmUnsxWkFROvbk0DFhBv/gZIlpHClYzPb5zM7YqtaV3pXQ5X9dq7q
c5e
-
sg2ufvL8CET8Ri3f554F4xmnWFYJHihjiA5r3p5tjyQc/03PfD6w8G68zA097bTs
-

6eRVbXKEFimGprjexXaJaj3aYlwUewTlBOYluwxIs72SfDmeuh6LBZP4DNeBkCk
V
-

/tdgvmiIW7ukTieB1uu5UH6Jhi9Ua46Rg+6l272Vc9ypuABOOu7JEA5YHd80r/ha
-

aSCEXBGkr20nXBO+Wg/SlzXL9y291IiOwAmLm4ZVD0GDUU+yXj3301dQ5YyA9
eLs
-

6gO5H+6RdyhbcYIigOrsxbGsn1MbLq64ilymcpOC+uSotuYQA+havNn8gZt1STA
d
-

affgqLRWZyE0wkQyT5BvzdH0KfI9LxeBakYCUxBibxfhXS4PZP4hMQBF77oRDN
gC
-EnHbvulVqOxVMfBfNEPPSl0tY5G29dJsdcUUMQ==
-=3HiN

+bGxlckBhcGFjaGUub3JnPokCOAQTAQIAIgUCTBZAxAIbAwYLCQgHAwIGFQg
CCQoL

+BBYCAwECHgECF4AACgkQP7/Rgnh5asgpcw/9FBpY3saaiidDWmmV20uM5W
PieQL5

+m4tkegSqwiscQKexIPomFwWk0lshc1tHelW2iC2bkemitc1eC3qFLz33MM5ft3
Gp

+mMTFQMIBf/XNw4OeE/tIp7lQwNbo5yCHFku+N6gLAdkzgHcNz87wPvL8PO
35oXMX

+lUWwUTUc5DxYk4IsnE7+xqEL/CctsT2hXPbqhnBYqS3zryX3DlkMELNFceSnXV
BY

+H0PjtFv48npjIWxCR2CsXQh/Xj5Spqx3tF0a5iUw3XeoH0HAeCzKywKzx7W8p
VuL

+9KLTbGfCC9WCiMzAL2yIsFjKqjPuAXfFeKEnOeRn7d/eAchZnY8BmtwpqHle1
Ahh

+SmsSUA0wbOEFlsIU4sBg+C6g7fL7ZvurwMdDPenJXZJJet/y4RdtsKWMDc7S2
okr

+FZzRHrfKoJczt/CuUuXqY8XfEGuh/nRpeFNTscFzA3cOkluPbYKQGshhUsICVX
yx

++6FXzXGtNlZ6Yb45DUiEuzmNurlcbktBbWuK9tgfaAY+U8mSc7mFsxrRQTUC3
AKH

+YZUlaMFKHIBwXCZMyp2K+tFU7dVivdP2NylytovGIlTKyT4ymbYlj9skzxqZxDI
W

+UI0QFtZXExCMvfGT7cuB3IFC0ZtdshT5hDYn9S2xbskRn1+aQSZLJOr8G/k27dC
3

+jOhgRE4hWnqFNYa5Ag0ETBZAxAEQAPjx6P0V3LALSkkfHn09NZLur57NrPnM
ahSH

+wuGDXGJfze1HqAyGa9Z5AD7HY8QwU1demP0DyzMITtGmYu/xRt/ifo6cbfY
8zQPE

+PGE8FpdP0rFzDntWgNR3j9R+F5R8ycE+h5jMA1qAB21D9HmKG/dr/dCSfa3f5
29A

+90f4Mb7oSvBGWin4Vj1XL6amMM12Yw7554qF+HYBPTouC9Dsr5o+Y+PzQzZ
dLPMu

+k/Yqebw4iMtC4SPFxm4aEPb2mxPQSAbCSBv0ry2o4r0r0llzxLbLZDbFPLsDsrat

+LGxzmuft17GgO/xIIRPquqLUkwO6J0GP4myPapPr/VoHocODncAQCZx8Mpu
LXEma

+tElN8xdxGDR244dDUSR/0q4pbOzsCgVr/eaQJL6ecVocrOQYOW/vx8E4TGUC
uumm

+Q5jFUUWomTNBBgW0KScDkLzmjYIJ31CoShQoj+yLfWdV9g7mHG8RUKyYF6
/M2d7A

+1O2OvrH+UFS3DILIBWHVOz8p6r3G7cLNqH0bVxOXA68UPtoE91woaSxA7P8
PxPlJ

+mYIlK+ZkYHMK48iHn6tUkMtdAK1/Ak+yA0R9EuVUed+0507egl/y9hcGQagne
TvO

+IllMAklsZRYU6FPTTgJzKWUcHirnPGvxa2Y6jxe5DrvCDSYmzkZSlkJ55FSTp3pu

+e5boBoDNABEBAAGJAh8EGAECAAkFAkwWQMQCGwwACgkQP7/Rgnh5asi
FjRAAv6TB

+h8PQkaQq2sxyqdQM6vtcCShwJy68/eZNmhZ8kp5cEMYTBW4qbqqh6CGGYy
VJ0KZ5

+g8Ilq7kBZB7G0IH/6VtxB0N6JwAr1o+mwgu2L5JuFpw6MHAkyAknHeXNFCFA
CN23

+lvEM+SIViFs0fPgT2woq2oeVjk1zA8NwJKV2XYNbaChAMFJ0Re70TLPH6cSCzS
TC

+8dQibwd2FcA5USqgbpn0+Bdoby7u1LsHhA4SBg/YdChJAuNvp6KDRKdLwrt/z
HxL

+iNRWXkXqXAme+GcvF/2vQ37llGkcXIJnjAITAHX0rYtPKeEfZtYhhi8wstqJof0w

+3sxSi4fZjcqbkUl68EjVrZkaGpn2/KxPu2QtK5JNv+AtYyq2BU7P7PIWYSo/KwcR

+EKerVh7fYRAhhzrB/wK/XPYonPIxNE8Qq1tRa6JzjFDDO4VtYp6mxtVCMxikfb
Pt

+PSmivA0RsSuDfM1qUMEJjso3WPSNNP/GG+r6cTe6g4l6WWM9i0ncrx/vQ20
03+SQ

+/x3mtXNQUihZAK82/aqhitd1Zi/cN+lsITBj4B4rfFIUOhXh9UivYyjWsJGklCcs

+bUIToYedGfq4XyopJE/C49qGO5/xmXRBByuGP3ESRMLwdMoe3dIEBMBFlqv
r267C
+5MNuLYxBjO6nun+BZ834FLWDVt1qKpQtd01g9ZM=
+=L5LB
   -----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----

   pub   4096R/E1EE085F 2009-11-05




---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] For
additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]



--
- Mark

http://www.lucidimagination.com

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] For additional
commands, e-mail: [email protected]



---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]



--
- Mark

http://www.lucidimagination.com

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]

Reply via email to