[
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SOLR-6220?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel&focusedCommentId=14255653#comment-14255653
]
Noble Paul commented on SOLR-6220:
----------------------------------
bq.N shards evenly distributed between D datacenters (for this case assume N is
evenly divisible by D)
This does not. Is it realy helpful to have just some shards in a DC? The design
distributes every shard
bq.All replicas should be in separate racks (unless there is no other choice)
bq.All replicas should be on separate hosts (unless there is no other choice)
not yet. Would be a nice syntax to add
> Replica placement strategy for solrcloud
> ----------------------------------------
>
> Key: SOLR-6220
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SOLR-6220
> Project: Solr
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: SolrCloud
> Reporter: Noble Paul
> Assignee: Noble Paul
>
> h1.Objective
> Most cloud based systems allow to specify rules on how the replicas/nodes of
> a cluster are allocated . Solr should have a flexible mechanism through which
> we should be able to control allocation of replicas or later change it to
> suit the needs of the system
> All configurations are per collection basis. The rules are applied whenever a
> replica is created in any of the shards in a given collection during
> * collection creation
> * shard splitting
> * add replica
> * createsshard
> There are two aspects to how replicas are placed: snitch and placement.
> h2.snitch
> How to identify the tags of nodes. Snitches are configured through collection
> create command with the snitch prefix . eg: snitch.type=EC2Snitch.
> The system provides the following implicit tag names which cannot be used by
> other snitches
> * node : The solr nodename
> * host : The hostname
> * ip : The ip address of the host
> * cores : This is a dynamic varibale which gives the core count at any given
> point
> * disk : This is a dynamic variable which gives the available disk space at
> any given point
> There will a few snitches provided by the system such as
> h3.EC2Snitch
> Provides two tags called dc, rack from the region and zone values in EC2
> h3.IPSnitch
> Use the IP to infer the “dc” and “rack” values
> h3.NodePropertySnitch
> This lets users provide system properties to each node with tagname and value
> .
> example : -Dsolrcloud.snitch.vals=tag-x:val-a,tag-y:val-b. This means this
> particular node will have two tags “tag-x” and “tag-y” .
>
> h3.RestSnitch
> Which lets the user configure a url which the server can invoke and get all
> the tags for a given node.
> This takes extra parameters in create command
> example:
> {{snitch.type=RestSnitch&snitch.url=http://snitchserverhost:port?nodename={}}}
> The response of the rest call
> {{http://snitchserverhost:port/?nodename=192.168.1:8080_solr}}
> must be in either json format or properties format.
> eg:
> {code:JavaScript}
> {
> “tag-x”:”x-val”,
> “tag-y”:”y-val”
> }
> {code}
> or
> {noformat}
> tag-x=x-val
> tag-y=y-val
> {noformat}
> h3.ManagedSnitch
> This snitch keeps a list of nodes and their tag value pairs in Zookeeper. The
> user should be able to manage the tags and values of each node through a
> collection API
> h2.Placement
> This tells how many replicas for a given shard needs to be assigned to nodes
> with the given key value pairs. These parameters will be passed on to the
> collection CREATE api as a parameter "placement" . The values will be saved
> in the state of the collection as follows
> {code:Javascript}
> {
> “mycollection”:{
> “snitch”: {
> type:“EC2Snitch”
> }
> “placement”:{
> “key1”: “value1”,
> “key2”: “value2”,
> }
> }
> {code}
> A rule consists of 2 parts
> * LHS or the qualifier .The format is
> \{shardname}.\{replicacount}\{quantifier} . Use the wild card “*” for
> qualifying all. quatifiers are
> ** no value means . exactly equal. e.g: 2 means exactly 2
> ** "+" means greater than or equal . e.g : 2+means 2 or more
> ** "\-" means less than. e.g 2- means , less than 2
> * RHS or conditions : The format is \{tagname}\{operand}\{value} . The tag
> name and values are provided by the snitch. The supported operands are
> ** -> : equals
> ** > : greater than . Only applicable for numeric tags
> ** < : less than , Only applicable to numeric tags
> ** ! : NOT or not equals
> Each collection can have any number of rules. As long as the rules do not
> conflict with each other it should be OK. Or else an error is thrown
> Example rules:
> * “shard1.1”:“dc->dc1,rack->168” : This would assign exactly 1 replica for
> shard1 with nodes having tags “dc=dc1,rack=168”.
> * “shard1.1+”:“dc->dc1,rack->168” : Same as above but assigns atleast one
> replica to the tag val combination
> * “*.1”:“dc->dc1” : For all shards keep exactly one replica in dc:dc1
> * “*.1+”:”dc->dc2” : At least one replica needs to be in dc:dc2
> * “*.2-”:”dc->dc3” : Keep a maximum of 2 replicas in dc:dc3 for all shards
> * “shard1.*”:”rack->730” : All replicas of shard1 will go to rack 730
> * “shard1.1”:“node->192.167.1.2:8983_solr” : 1 replica of shard1 must go to
> the node 192.167.1.28983_solr
> * “shard1.* : “rack!738” : No replica of shard1 should go to rack 738
> * “shard1.* : “host!192.168.89.91” : No replica of shard1 should go to host
> 192.168.89.91
> * “\*.*”: “cores<5”: All replicas should be created in nodes with less than
> 5 cores
> * “\*.*”:”disk>20gb” : All replicas must be created in nodes with disk
> space greater than 20gb
> In the collection create API all the placement rules are provided as a
> parameter called placement and multiple rules are separated with "|"
> example:
> {noformat}
> snitch.type=EC2Snitch&placement=*.1:dc->dc1|*.2-:dc->dc3|shard1.*:rack!738
> {noformat}
--
This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA
(v6.3.4#6332)
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscr...@lucene.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-h...@lucene.apache.org
