Erick - I commented on LUCENE-9448 (I made a mistake with issue # in previous comment).
> And if the consensus is that we should consider it a developer’s tool rather than something we make available to casual users, I can just close SOLR-13412 as “won’t fix". I suspect the tool is not for "casual users" :) Meanwhile, a bit surprisingly to be honest, the old Luke github repo earns 1.4k stars now; seems like a certain number of Solr (and elasticsearch) users need Luke. Personally I don't think it should be shipped with the default distribution, but it could be helpful for experienced users/developers if it can be easily downloaded somehow on demand. 2020年8月8日(土) 20:42 Erick Erickson <[email protected]>: > Tomoko: > > Agreed. What I’m curious about regardless of LUCENE-9442 is whether > building/distribution Luke is desirable. It’s not clear to me that we > _should_ package and distribute Luke with Solr and/or Lucene, It flies in > the face of the “slimmer faster Solr” effort. OTOH, if it’s a package, the > work we need to do in Solr is different than if we add it to the distro... > > And if the consensus is that we should consider it a developer’s tool > rather than something we make available to casual users, I can just close > SOLR-13412 as “won’t fix". > > > On Aug 7, 2020, at 11:15 PM, Tomoko Uchida <[email protected]> > wrote: > > > > Hi Erick, > > > > > 2> Currently, invoking it is an ant task, it’s not build/distributed. > How this will work out in the Gradle build is TBD. > > > > As for this point, I think we should consider SOLR-13412 and LUCENE-9442 > separately, since the former is about making a distribution package and the > latter is about providing a helper for developers. > > > > Tomoko > > > > > > 2020年8月7日(金) 22:28 Erick Erickson <[email protected]>: > > All: > > > > I’m not sure this really makes sense at this point. I’ve outlined the > current state on the JIRA. The sort form is: > > > > 1> there’s some work currently being done to make the stand-alone Luke > app work in the Gradle world. > > > > 2> Currently, invoking it is an ant task, it’s not build/distributed. > How this will work out in the Gradle build is TBD. > > > > 3> I’m not sure trying to make this easily accessible from Solr > ("bin/solr luke" or similar) even in the event that the Gradle build > creates the entire standalone app adds enough value to make it worth the > effort. We have a subset of functionality with the Luke Request Handler, > and people who need the deeper dive that Luke provides can download the > source and execute the Gradle task. > > > > So I’m thinking of closing the JIRA as “won’t fix”. > > > > Please add comments to the JIRA > > > > Erick > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > > To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] > > For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected] > > > > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] > For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected] > >
