Hi,

> To a certain extent I agree with this, but the long and short of it is
> that there is a place for both. Ever tried writing a novel in PageMaker
> or InDesign?

I'd say do that in an editor and do the layouting in a DTP application
afterwards. I bet the functionality of Writer used for writing a novel
is what...10%? Probably even less.

However, I'd much prefer to see a breakup of that whole concept and an
incarnation of a content/design separation joined seemlessly in a smart
UI as mentioned before.

> It's no more fun doing that than it is to lay out a
> magazine in Writer or Word. There is a place for both, and I think that
> a DTP application is a logical next step for the OOo project, but not
> until the existing components (such as Base) are more or less perfected.
> (Most of the components are close, but some--like Base--still have
> issues that need to be a priority.)

I agree to that.

> Honestly, a lot of businesses do have someone in their office do their
> website.

Yeah, but what do they work with, Frontpage? Or is it rather more often
the case that they have a DreamWeaver (or a text editor ;-) ) around?

> Should they? Well, that depends. I have seen some very nice
> websites done by people in their office using something like Frontpage.
> They are few and far between, but they do exist, and if you are a very
> small business, you do what you can with what you've got.

Only that i wonder if a program like Frontpage really helps that "what
you can". But i guess you are right, there surely are some businesses
who have a Frontpage created web page.

> It depends on your purpose. I mean, Framemaker is essentially a huge
> word processor, and it's great for technical projects in which you need
> an illustration to stay with your specific chunk of text. In fact, I'd
> love to see OOo have all of the capabilities of FM without the really
> heady structuring. (How cool would it be to be able to place
> illustrations and references to illustrations that all autonumber? Or to
> be able to refer to Illustration X on Page Y and have X and Y change
> according to where the text flow put the illustration?)

See, i think we are actually all thinking in the same direction. And XML
seems to be the right media for that.

André.

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to