Hi,

I was looking at applying the patch for this one, but wasn't happy with it and looked for a better solution, which I'm also not happy with :)

Basically, in the reactor target/classes is always used as the classpath for projects referring to dependencies inside the reactor because of the way it is set in MavenProject. I think it would be worth us reversing the logic in MavenProject (if the artifact file is not null, use that, if it is, use the active project) - any thoughts why that would be a bad idea?

As for shade, to make it work in the reactor, there's 3 options:
- unpack the final JAR into the classesDirectory (the original patch)
- replace the outputDirectory with the JAR (cleaner and more concise, but effectively makes the output directory read-only from the package phase, might have unexpected side effects if someone modifies the output afterwards, though that would seem unwise anyway) - don't fix it, require people to use <shadedArtifactAttached>true</ shadedArtifactAttached> instead and depend on the one with the classifier.

Opinions?

Cheers,
Brett

--
Brett Porter
[email protected]
http://blogs.exist.com/bporter/

Reply via email to