Lukas Theussl wrote: > > > Dennis Lundberg wrote: >> Lukas Theussl wrote: >>> Hi, >>> >>> I was looking at the jira roadmap for the site plugin, thinking about a >>> release plan for 2.1. The main change so far is the upgrade to doxia >>> 1.1, I think it would be a good idea to concentrate the next release on >>> issues that are related that. In particular, I'd like to fix all these >>> annoying bugs with links (eg MSITE-395, MSITE-404, MSITE-409 and many >>> others), which might necessitate another doxia release. >> >> It's good to keep the releases small and focused. So +1 from me for a >> special Doxia upgrade release. >> >> +1 also for fixing the path issues you mentioned in the near future. My >> findings on those issues are that the problem lies somewhere inside >> Doxia, so I think another Doxia release will be necessary. If that is >> the case, I think it is wise to do a release of the Site plugin with >> Doxia 1.1.1 first. > > > I have fixed DOXIASITETOOLS-29 and checked that MSITE-404 gets fixed > with it.
That's great news! One question on this though, as I read through your commits: Doesn't Doxia Sitetools need to upgrade it's dependency on Plexus Utils, since DOXIASITETOOLS-29 is related to PLXUTILS-116? Or did you work around PLXUTILS-116 in your patch for DOXIASITETOOLS-29? > My preference would be to bump the doxia dep in site-plugin to > 1.1.2-SNAP, and push the number of MSITE issues down, fixing doxia bugs > as we go along (finally we can use the site plugin to test doxia > again... :) ). Some of the open issues have blocker status so I don't > see the point of another site release before those are fixed. WDYT? I have difficulties making my mind up about this. On one hand I think it would be good to get Doxia 1.1.x out ASAP to have it tried in the real world. If we delay the real world deployment for too long, the jump might be to high to release it and it might also drag out over time. On the other hand I acknowledge that the issues you listed are very important to fix, because they are causing users a lot of grief. The blocker status has often been set by users rather than developers though. I do believe that MSITE-404 is the core of these issues and if that is fixed the others might be solved as well. Let's do a 1.1.2 release of Doxia and have Site plugin 2.1 use that version. But let us keep the number of bug fixes for 1.1.2 low, so that it can be released fairly soon. > > -Lukas > > >> >>> Right now there are also a number of other issues scheduled that are not >>> related (eg MSITE-79, MSITE-206, MSITE-326) which I would like to leave >>> out and schedule for a later release. >> >> +1 to leave those issues out. >> >>> >>> Is this ok with everyone? >>> -Lukas >>> >>> --------------------------------------------------------------------- >>> To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] >>> For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected] >>> >>> >> >> > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] > For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected] > > -- Dennis Lundberg --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]
