2010/8/4 Stephen Connolly <stephen.alan.conno...@gmail.com>: > I share concerns with respect to where the code is hosted. I recognise that > as Apache is a meritocracy, there is a barrier for other developers getting > involved. The Hudson model of "You want commit access, here you go" is a > tad too liberal for me, but the Apache model is too far the other way IMHO. > To some extend the codehaus model as practiced on mojo seems a good > compromise to me... but anyway aside from all that... > > Maven is hosted on Apache, therefore I feel that core Maven libraries should > be hosted on Apache until they have significant adoption elsewhere... the > Maven Repository API... well that kind of says it all as far as I'm > concerned with respect to where it should live. > > The Guice changes, well guice is widely adopted elsewhere, so I'm not > suggesting that Guice be relocated or forked into apache, but the Maven > specific parts of that integration.... hang about... "maven specific" says > it all again. > > I have always had concerns about plexus being pretty much only adopted by > Maven as far as I can see, and essentially being a maven core component, > except it isn't
+1 Guice allready as its own large community of users and maintainers. It's a general 'purpose' API. Aether is new, Maven related and need to create its own community. Why not moving it to ASF as a Maven subproject ? --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscr...@maven.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: dev-h...@maven.apache.org
