I think this is ok, these ids are not part of the component tree. They should only be unique within the same form. If a form submits it only post the input fields inside the form so it is necessary to put them into each form.
2005/9/29, Mike Kienenberger <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: > I'm seeing duplicate jsf_state_64, jsf_tree_64 and jsf_viewid ids > with multiple forms on a page. Each form has all three ids. Aren't > ids supposed to be unique across a page? > > At first I wondered if this was a facelets problem, but I see the same > behavior with a standard jsp page. > -- Mathias
