Hi! > I know it's not this clear-cut, but the end result (even if it takes > some intermediate workarounds like generating wrapping form > components) should be to require these things to be inside a form. Yes, I am completely with every who thinks we should deprecate the dummyForm at all.
As I wrote already, embedding within an form also requires some assumptions about the JSF impl we should not take. So to make the migration for existing applications easier I try to do some ViewHandler hacks (if this will work) and log a warning for every UICommand component not inside an UIForm. Hopefully this will convince everyone to move away from DummyForm. --- Mario