I personally think that we should stay with 1.X and drop trunk for now. In future, we could integrate in smaller steps features from trunk into 1.X, for example in versions 1.4, 1.5,... Doing so huge leap into 2.0 now will do no good for this project, since recently there is no much committers doing actual commits.
2009/12/8 Tammo van Lessen <tvanles...@gmail.com>: > Hi ODE devs, > > on the IRC channel, we had in interesting discussion yesterday about the > current branch situation and I (have been :)) volunteered to raise this > issue here. Although /trunk has been communicated to be the successor of > the 1.x branch, development still goes on on 1.x so that we basically > have two development branches currently. This leads to the predicament > that each fix has to be created, reviewed and committed twice and makes > it difficult to track whether both branches are sync (i.e. all bug fixes > have been ported to the respective other branch. Rafal and I think that > we don't really have the resources to maintain two development branches > and we should drop one. The important question actually is, which one. > > Scenario I: Discontinue and drop trunk and continue development 1.x > Scenario II: Discontinue 1.x and move on with trunk > > I personally would really regret choosing Scenario I, since trunk has > couple of great new feature such as the new IL, OModel versioning, > extension activities, process contexts, etc., and that with good cause. > Not to mention the hard work that has been put into that branch. So it's > rather not an option. > > Scenario II has IMHO less of such negative impact. We will still need to > maintain the 1.x branch for bug fixes of running 1.x instances, so we're > not dropping something, however, all new features should go into > trunk. In addition, it's rather impossible to stabilize and improve > trunk with respect to performance etc. if it is not released. > > My suggestion would be to go for II, prepare a 1.3.4 and 2.0-beta2 > release, declare 1.x to be a dead-end and move on with development on trunk. > > What do you think? > > Cheers, > Tammo > Regards, -- Rafał Rusin http://rrusin.blogspot.com http://www.touk.pl http://top.touk.pl
