No, it is not a vote for a POC. If the community agrees we need to make
a change, then we can create a Jira issue, branch, POC, etc.
No one is going to go to all that work if in the end the community says
"Nope, don't want it."
Adrian Crum
Sandglass Software
www.sandglass-software.com
On 4/26/2015 9:16 PM, Michael Brohl wrote:
Adrian,
that's what I tried to say and what Ron asked: if it's a vote for a POC
and not a final decision to replace OFBiz with Moqui: +1
The vote title is not about a POC but about a decision to begin
replacing. For me this sounds like a difference. Might be a language
problem on my side.
Michael Brohl
ecomify GmbH
www.ecomify.de
Am 26.04.15 um 21:27 schrieb Adrian Crum:
No one is going to invest their time and effort in a POC unless they
have the approval and support of the community. I don't think you're
going to see a POC before a vote.
Adrian Crum
Sandglass Software
www.sandglass-software.com
On 4/26/2015 6:39 PM, Michael Brohl wrote:
-1 (not binding)
This is *not* a vote against moving to Moqui or replacing parts of OFBiz
with Moqui or...
I simply feel there is not enough discussion, deeper insights in the
effects, a clear path how to do it etc., at least for me. I would prefer
to have some scenarios described, take a deeper look at the effects,
estimate the efforts and resources etc.
No real company would set up a project of replacing their base products'
framwork with another one based on the available informations and
estimations.
"Begin replacing OFBiz Framework With Moqui": *-1* (right now)
"Begin to organise a PoC, have a deeper discussion and gather more
facts": *+1*
Michael
ecomify GmbH
www.ecomify.de
Am 26.04.15 um 16:44 schrieb Adrian Crum:
As was discussed last week, there is some interest in replacing some
(or all) of OFBiz with Moqui
(http://www.moqui.org/framework/index.html).
To the scope reasonable, I propose that we begin by converting the
following parts of the OFBiz framework with Moqui:
Entity Engine
Service Engine
Security
Other parts of the OFBiz framework could be converted as well, but I
think this would be a good starting point, and if is successful, then
more of OFBiz can be converted later.
I believe we can create a thunk component to help solve compatibility
problems, but that is a separate discussion. I only mention it here in
case compatibility concerns might influence a vote.
