Am 15.08.2011 20:22, schrieb master_axe:
regarding your OSM History Splitter:

If I have a full planet dump(including history, bz2), and I want to cut a BB
out of it, your OSM History Splitter is the tool to use?
yep.


So this would be the counter piece to say, osmosis (for current data only)?
It is a subset of osmosis (cutting only) that is also capable of history data.

I ask because I recently made a small change to osmosis to read and write
the visibility tag, and in parallel found a perl script to extract history
(history-excerpt.pl)(I'm guessing these two do the same thing now). What's
the difference?
 - the history-splitter is faster ;)
- it does requiree less ram (for the same features) with the tradeof of reading the file twice (but its usually still faster) - it is able to take its cutting-polygons from special .osm files (only closed ways are used)

- when using the --softcut mode, it keeps the history of objects complete; so if one version is inside the bbox, all versions are copied

Peter

_______________________________________________
dev mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/dev

Reply via email to